This study examines the role of social norms in the context of entertainment media selection based on social identity theory and the theory of normative social behavior. Participants who self-identified as White American, Asian/Asian American, or Black/African American were solicited to complete an online survey regarding media selection, as well as identity strength, perceived norms surrounding entertainment consumption, and media habits. The results indicate that in-group preference and identity predicted media selection, such that people selected films featuring members from their own demographic groups. Yet, in-group media selections were also influenced by social norms. Although participants overall preferred movies featuring in-group actors, the driving factor for in-group media selection differed across groups. For White participants, in-group media selection was influenced by in-group preference. However, social norms were main predictors for Asian participants' in-group media selection. Neither norms nor in-group preference predicted Black participants' media selection.