The Happiness of the Wicked: How Tokugawa Thinkers Dealt with the Problem

被引:0
|
作者
Ansart, Olivier [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Sydney, Dept Japanese Studies, Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
关键词
D O I
10.1080/09552367.2012.692975
中图分类号
C [社会科学总论];
学科分类号
03 ; 0303 ;
摘要
Phenomena like the happiness of the wicked or the misfortune of the worthies were for Confucian thinkers, just as for Christian theologians, puzzles that their 'theories on fortune and misfortune', just like Theodicies in the West, were trying, with some difficulty, to explain or rationalize. This article first surveys some standard explanations of the phenomena given by scholars of eighteenth-century Japan within the framework of the available monist, rationalist paradigms. Afterward, it turns to another type of representation of the world that could answer the puzzles-not, it should be stressed, by solving them, but rather by dis-solving them: by making them disappear as problems. In this new representation, for which many inhabitants of industrialized societies today have much affinity, the world in which humans live is ruled by many independent and mutually irreducible rationalities-economic, productive, military, moral (under various forms), political, physical, etc. If humans view the world in such manner, they are certainly confronted by many questions-for example the need to order or prioritize those logics in order to achieve an overarching order-but they are delivered at least of one burden: the necessity to justify scandals like the happiness of the wicked. Most such tragedies arise then simply from the encounter of different rationalities qua independent rationalities: say, the encounter of the physical laws that produce devastating earthquakes with the moral principles that lead us to attach value to human lives. There is no mystery to explain, just a tragedy to lament. The article thus captures the most important developments in political, social and economic thought of the Japanese eighteenth century through the concept of concurrent rationalities, following the thread of the treatments of the puzzle of the happy villains.
引用
收藏
页码:161 / 175
页数:15
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Happiness as a Problem
    Profaca, Maja
    [J]. FILOZOFSKA ISTRAZIVANJA, 2009, 29 (04): : 763 - 773
  • [42] . How the Zamuco languages dealt with verb affixes
    Bertinetto, Pier Marco
    [J]. WORD STRUCTURE, 2011, 4 (02) : 215 - 230
  • [43] How to deal with wicked anaphora?
    Cristea, D
    Postolache, OD
    [J]. ANAPHORA PROCESSING: LINGUISTIC, COGNITIVE AND COMPUTATIONAL MODELLING, 2004, 263 : 17 - 46
  • [44] How metal scenes dealt with the pandemic: An introduction
    Bardine, Bryan
    Stueart, Jerome
    [J]. METAL MUSIC STUDIES, 2024, 10 (02) : 85 - 90
  • [45] Sleep apnoea and driving: how can this be dealt with?
    Krieger, J.
    [J]. EUROPEAN RESPIRATORY REVIEW, 2007, 16 (106): : 189 - 195
  • [46] Iceland: how social mechanisms drove the financial collapse and why it's a wicked problem
    Duffy, Sarah Maree
    Northey, Gavin
    van Esch, Patrick
    [J]. JOURNAL OF SOCIAL MARKETING, 2017, 7 (03) : 330 - 346
  • [47] Minamata: how a policy maker addressed a very wicked water quality policy problem
    Kobayashi, Hikaru
    [J]. WATER INTERNATIONAL, 2018, 43 (03) : 404 - 423
  • [48] The How of Happiness
    Long, Terry
    [J]. THERAPEUTIC RECREATION JOURNAL, 2008, 42 (04) : 251 - 252
  • [49] Fatal MDR Klebsiella in ICU - How was it Dealt with?
    Khandelwal, Vipul
    Sharma, Shruti
    [J]. INDIAN JOURNAL OF CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE, 2019, 23 (09) : 411 - 413
  • [50] HOW BUSINESS HAS DEALT WITH POLITICAL RISK
    VANAGTMAEL, AW
    [J]. FINANCIAL EXECUTIVE, 1976, 44 (01): : 26 - 30