Coronary Computed Tomographic Angiography and Risk of All-Cause Mortality and Nonfatal Myocardial Infarction in Subjects Without Chest Pain Syndrome From the CONFIRM Registry (Coronary CT Angiography Evaluation for Clinical Outcomes: An International Multicenter Registry)

被引:165
|
作者
Cho, Iksung [1 ]
Chang, Hyuk-Jae [1 ,2 ]
Sung, Ji Min [3 ]
Pencina, Michael J. [4 ]
Lin, Fay Y. [5 ]
Dunning, Allison M. [6 ,7 ]
Achenbach, Stephan [8 ]
Al-Mallah, Mouaz [9 ]
Berman, Daniel S. [10 ]
Budoff, Matthew J. [11 ]
Callister, Tracy Q.
Chow, Benjamin J. W. [12 ]
Delago, Augustin [13 ]
Hadamitzky, Martin [14 ]
Hausleiter, Joerg [14 ]
Maffei, Erica [15 ,16 ]
Cademartiri, Filippo [15 ,16 ]
Kaufmann, Philipp [17 ]
Shaw, Leslee J. [18 ]
Raff, Gil L. [19 ]
Chinnaiyan, Kavitha M. [19 ]
Villines, Todd C. [20 ]
Cheng, Victor [21 ]
Nasir, Khurram [22 ,23 ,24 ]
Gomez, Millie [25 ]
Min, James K. [25 ]
机构
[1] Severance Cardiovasc Hosp, Div Cardiol, Seoul, South Korea
[2] Severance Biomed Sci Inst, Seoul, South Korea
[3] Yonsei Univ, Coll Med, Dept Res Affairs, Seoul 120752, South Korea
[4] Boston Univ, Dept Biostat, Boston, MA 02215 USA
[5] Univ Erlangen Nurnberg, Dept Med, D-91054 Erlangen, Germany
[6] Weill Cornell Med Coll, Dept Publ Hlth, New York, NY USA
[7] New York Presbyterian Hosp, New York, NY USA
[8] Univ Giessen, Dept Cardiol, Giessen, Germany
[9] Wayne State Univ, Dept Med, Henry Ford Hosp, Detroit, MI 48202 USA
[10] Cedars Sinai Med Ctr, Dept Cardiac Imaging, Los Angeles, CA 90048 USA
[11] Harbor UCLA Med Ctr, Dept Med, Los Angeles, CA USA
[12] Univ Ottawa, Inst Heart, Dept Med & Radiol, Ottawa, ON, Canada
[13] Capitol Cardiol Assoc, Albany, NY USA
[14] Deutsch Herzzentrum Munich, Div Cardiol, Munich, Germany
[15] Erasmus Med Ctr Univ, Dept Radiol, Rotterdam, Netherlands
[16] Giovanni XXIII Hosp, Cardiovasc Imaging Unit, Monastier Di Treviso, Italy
[17] Univ Zurich Hosp, CH-8091 Zurich, Switzerland
[18] Emory Univ, Sch Med, Div Cardiol, Atlanta, GA 30322 USA
[19] William Beaumont Hosp, Dept Cardiol, Royal Oak, MI 48072 USA
[20] Walter Reed Natl Mil Med Ctr, Serv Cardiol, Bethesda, MD USA
[21] Oklahoma Heart Inst, Dept Cardiovasc CT, Tulsa, OK USA
[22] Baptist Hlth S Florida, Miami, FL USA
[23] Johns Hopkins Univ, Sch Med, Ciccarone Prevent Cardiol Ctr, Baltimore, MD USA
[24] Harbor UCLA, Los Angeles Biomed Res Inst, Torrance, CA USA
[25] Cedars Sinai Med Ctr, Dept Med, Cedars Sinai Heart Inst, Los Angeles, CA 90048 USA
基金
瑞士国家科学基金会;
关键词
asymptomatic; coronary artery calcium; coronary CT angiography; prognosis; CARDIOVASCULAR-MAGNETIC-RESONANCE; SCREENING ASYMPTOMATIC SUBJECTS; INCREMENTAL PROGNOSTIC VALUE; NORTH-AMERICAN-SOCIETY; ARTERY CALCIUM SCORE; NUCLEAR-CARDIOLOGY; SUBCLINICAL ATHEROSCLEROSIS; HEART-ASSOCIATION; WORKING GROUP; TASK-FORCE;
D O I
10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.111.081380
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Background-The predictive value of coronary computed tomographic angiography (cCTA) in subjects without chest pain syndrome (CPS) has not been established. We investigated the prognostic value of coronary artery disease detection by cCTA and determined the incremental risk stratification benefit of cCTA findings compared with clinical risk factor scoring and coronary artery calcium scoring (CACS) for individuals without CPS. Methods and Results-An open-label, 12-center, 6-country observational registry of 27 125 consecutive patients undergoing cCTA and CACS was queried, and 7590 individuals without CPS or history of coronary artery disease met the inclusion criteria. All-cause mortality and the composite of all-cause mortality and nonfatal myocardial infarction were measured. During a median follow-up of 24 months (interquartile range, 18-35 months), all-cause mortality occurred in 136 individuals. After risk adjustment, compared with individuals without evidence of coronary artery disease by cCTA, individuals with obstructive 2- and 3-vessel disease or left main coronary artery disease experienced higher rates of death and composite outcome (P<0.05 for both). Both CACS and cCTA significantly improved the performance of standard risk factor prediction models for all-cause mortality and the composite outcome (likelihood ratio P<0.05 for all), but the incremental discriminatory value associated with their inclusion was more pronounced for the composite outcome and for CACS (C statistic for model with risk factors only was 0.71; for risk factors plus CACS, 0.75; for risk factors plus CACS plus cCTA, 0.77). The net reclassification improvement resulting from the addition of cCTA to a model based on standard risk factors and CACS was negligible. Conclusions-Although the prognosis for individuals without CPS is stratified by cCTA, the additional risk-predictive advantage by cCTA is not clinically meaningful compared with a risk model based on CACS. Therefore, at present, the application of cCTA for risk assessment of individuals without CPS should not be justified. (Circulation. 2012; 126: 304-313.)
引用
收藏
页码:304 / +
页数:17
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] ATHEROSCLEROTIC CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE RISK IN STATIN-NAIVE ASYMPTOMATIC PATIENTS WITH NON-OBSTRUCTIVE CORONARY ARTERY DISEASE DETECTED BY CORONARY COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHIC ANGIOGRAPHY: THE CONFIRM-LT (CORONARY CT ANGIOGRAPHY EVALUATION FOR CLINICAL OUTCOMES: AN INTERNATIONAL MULTICENTER) REGISTRY
    Beecy, Ashley
    Han, Donghee
    Hartaigh, Brain O.
    Anchouche, Khalil
    Al'Aref, Subhi
    Gransar, Heidi
    Lee, Ji Hyun
    Park, Mahn Won
    Roudsari, Hadi Mirhedayati
    Rizvi, Asim
    Lin, Fay
    Min, James
    Pena, Jessica M.
    JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY, 2017, 69 (11) : 1829 - 1829
  • [22] Incremental Prognostic Value of Cardiac Computed Tomography in Coronary Artery Disease Using CONFIRM COroNary Computed Tomography Angiography Evaluation for Clinical Outcomes: An InteRnational Multicenter Registry
    Chow, Benjamin J. W.
    Small, Gary
    Yam, Yeung
    Chen, Li
    Achenbach, Stephan
    Al-Mallah, Mouaz
    Berman, Daniel S.
    Budoff, Matthew J.
    Cademartiri, Filippo
    Callister, Tracy Q.
    Chang, Hyuk-Jae
    Cheng, Victor
    Chinnaiyan, Kavitha M.
    Delago, Augustin
    Dunning, Allison
    Hadamitzky, Martin
    Hausleiter, Joerg
    Kaufmann, Philipp
    Lin, Fay
    Maffei, Erica
    Raff, Gilbert L.
    Shaw, Leslee J.
    Villines, Todd C.
    Min, James K.
    CIRCULATION-CARDIOVASCULAR IMAGING, 2011, 4 (05) : 463 - 472
  • [23] Invasive Coronary Angiography, Revascularization, and Adverse Cardiac Events Following CCTA: A Matched Analysis of Women and Men in the Prospective Multinational CONFIRM Registry (Coronary CT Angiography Evaluation for Clinical Outcomes: An International Multicenter Registry)
    Lin, Fay Y.
    Shaw, Leslee J.
    Dunning, Allison M.
    Chinnaiyan, Kavitha
    Achenbach, Stephan
    Al-Mallah, Mouaz
    Berman, Daniel S.
    Budoff, Matthew J.
    Cademartiri, Filippo
    Callister, Tracy Q.
    Chang, Hyuk-Jae
    Cheng, Victor Y.
    Chow, Benjamin J.
    Delago, Augustin J.
    Hadamitzky, Martin
    Hausleiter, Joerg
    Karlsberg, Ronald P.
    Kaufmann, Philipp A.
    Leipsic, Jonathon
    Maffei, Erica
    Raff, Gilbert L.
    Villines, Todd C.
    Min, James K.
    CIRCULATION, 2011, 124 (21)
  • [24] IMPACT OF CORONARY ARTERY CALCIFICATION SCORE ON PROGNOSIS OF INDIVIDUALS WITH AND WITHOUT METABOLIC SYNDROME; RESULTS FROM THE MULTINATIONAL CORONARY CT ANGIOGRAPHY EVALUATION FOR CLINICAL OUTCOME: AN INTERNATIONAL MULTICENTER REGISTRY (CONFIRM)
    Ahmadi, Amir
    Min, James
    Raju, Rekha
    Achenbach, Stephan
    Precious, Bruce
    Al-Mallah, Mouaz
    Berman, Daniel
    Budoff, Matthew
    Cademartiri, Filippo
    Callister, Tracy
    Chang, Hyuk-Jae
    Chinnaiyan, Kavitha
    Chow, Benjamin
    Cury, Ricardo
    Gransar, Heidi
    Feuchtner, Gudrun
    Gomez, Millie
    Hadamitzky, Martin
    Kaufmann, Philipp
    Lin, Fay
    Raff, Gilbert
    Shaw, Leslee
    Villines, Todd
    Leipsic, Jonathan
    JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY, 2014, 63 (12) : A1060 - A1060
  • [25] Prognostic and Therapeutic Implications of Statin and Aspirin Therapy in Individuals With Nonobstructive Coronary Artery Disease Results From the CONFIRM (Coronary CT Angiography Evaluation For Clinical Outcomes: An International Multicenter Registry) Registry
    Chow, Benjamin J. W.
    Small, Gary
    Yam, Yeung
    Chen, Li
    McPherson, Ruth
    Achenbach, Stephan
    Al-Mallah, Mouaz
    Berman, Daniel S.
    Budoff, Matthew J.
    Cademartiri, Filippo
    Callister, Tracy Q.
    Chang, Hyuk-Jae
    Cheng, Victor Y.
    Chinnaiyan, Kavitha
    Cury, Ricardo
    Delago, Augustin
    Dunning, Allison
    Feuchtner, Gundrun
    Hadamitzky, Martin
    Hausleiter, Joerg
    Karlsberg, Ronald P.
    Kaufmann, Philipp A.
    Kim, Yong-Jin
    Leipsic, Jonathon
    LaBounty, Troy
    Lin, Fay
    Maffei, Erica
    Ralf, Gilbert L.
    Shaw, Leslee J.
    Villines, Todd C.
    Min, James K.
    ARTERIOSCLEROSIS THROMBOSIS AND VASCULAR BIOLOGY, 2015, 35 (04) : 981 - U271
  • [26] Framingham Risk Score Predicts Probability of Significant Coronary Artery Stenosis in Stable Symptomatic Patients: Results from the Multinational CONFIRM Registry (Coronary CT Angiography Evaluation for Clinical Outcomes: An International Multicenter Registry)
    Cheng, Victor
    Berman, Daniel S.
    Dunning, Allison
    Achenbach, Stephan
    Al-Mallah, Mouaz
    Budoff, Matthew J.
    Callister, Tracy Q.
    Chang, Hyuk-Jae
    Chow, Benjamin
    Delago, Augustin
    Hadamitzky, Martin
    Hausleiter, Joerg
    Karlsberg, Ronald P.
    Kaufmann, Philipp
    Lin, Fay Y.
    Min, James K.
    Nasir, Khurram
    Shaw, Leslee J.
    CIRCULATION, 2010, 122 (21)
  • [27] Absence of Coronary Artery Disease by Coronary Computed Tomographic Angiography and the Warranty Period Associated With All-Cause Mortality: Findings From the CONFIRM Long-Term Follow-Up Registry
    Cho, Lksung
    Hartaigh, Briain O.
    Gransar, Heidi
    -Marcus, Joshua Schulman
    Valenti, Valentina
    Berman, Daniel S.
    Budoff, Matthew J.
    Achenbach, Stephan
    Al-Mallah, Mouaz
    Andreini, Daniele
    Cademartiri, Filippo
    Callister, Tracy Q.
    Chang, Hyuk-Jae
    Chinnaiyan, Kavitha
    Cury, Ricardo
    Delago, Augustin
    Gomez, Millie
    Hadamitzky, Martin
    Hausleiter, Joerg
    Hindoyan, Niree
    Feuchtner, Gudrun
    Kim, Yong-Jin
    Kaufmann, Philipp A.
    Leipsic, Jonathon
    Lin, Fay Y.
    Maffei, Erica
    Pontone, Gianluca
    Raff, Gilbert
    Shaw, Leslee J.
    Villines, Todd C.
    Dunning, Allison
    Min, James K.
    CIRCULATION, 2014, 130
  • [28] GENDER DIFFERENCES IN ALL-CAUSE DEATH BY EXTENT AND SEVERITY OF CORONARY ARTERY DISEASE BY CARDIAC COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHIC ANGIOGRAPHY: A MATCHED ANALYSIS OF THE CONFIRM REGISTRY
    Lin, Fay
    Chinnaiyan, Kavitha
    Dunning, Allison M.
    Shaw, Leslee J.
    Achenbach, Stephan
    Al-Mallah, Mouaz
    Berman, Daniel S.
    Budoff, Matthew J.
    Cademartiri, Filippo
    Callister, Tracy Q.
    Chang, Hyuk-Jae
    Chow, Benjamin J. W.
    Delago, Augustin J.
    Hausleiter, Joerg
    Hadamitzky, Martin
    Kaufmann, Philipp
    Raff, Gilbert L.
    Villines, Todd
    Min, James K.
    JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY, 2011, 57 (14) : E773 - E773
  • [29] SMOKING AND ITS RELATIONSHIP WITH LONG TERM EVENTS: FURTHER INSIGHTS FROM THE CONFIRM (CORONARY CT ANGIOGRAPHY EVALUATION FOR CLINICAL OUTCOMES: AN INTERNATIONAL MULTICENTER) REGISTRY
    Omid-Fard, Nima
    Ahmadi, Amir
    Blanke, Philipp
    Sellers, Stephanie
    Gransar, Heidi
    Berman, Daniel
    Callister, Tracy
    DeLago, Augustin
    Hadamitzky, Martin
    Hausleiter, Joerg
    Budoff, Matthew
    Kaufmann, Philipp
    Raff, Gilbert
    Chinnaiyan, Kavitha
    Villines, Todd
    Feuchtner, Gudrun
    Pontone, Gianluca
    Andreini, Daniele
    Marques, Hugo
    Rubinshtein, Ronen
    Achenbach, Stephan
    Shaw, Leslee
    Gomez, Millie
    Min, James
    Leipsic, Jonathon
    JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY, 2017, 69 (11) : 1593 - 1593
  • [30] Effects of cardiac medications for patients with obstructive coronary artery disease by coronary computed tomographic angiography: Results from the multicenter CONFIRM registry
    Schulman-Marcus, Joshua
    Hartaigh, Briain O.
    Giambrone, Ashley E.
    Gransar, Heidi
    Valenti, Valentina
    Berman, Daniel S.
    Budoff, Matthew J.
    Achenbach, Stephan
    Al-Mallah, Mouaz
    Andreini, Daniele
    Cademartiri, Filippo
    Callister, Tracy Q.
    Chang, Hyuk-Jae
    Chinnaiyan, Kavitha
    Chow, Benjamin J. W.
    Cury, Ricardo
    Delago, Augustin
    Hadamitzky, Martin
    Hausleiter, Joerg
    Feuchtner, Gudrun
    Kim, Yong-Jin
    Kaufmann, Philipp A.
    Leipsic, Jonathon
    Lin, Fay Y.
    Maffei, Erica
    Pontone, Gianluca
    Raff, Gilbert
    Shaw, Leslee J.
    Villines, Todd C.
    Dunning, Allison
    Min, James K.
    ATHEROSCLEROSIS, 2015, 238 (01) : 119 - 125