Did Romans regard plague as force majeure?

被引:0
|
作者
Sobczyk, Marek [1 ]
机构
[1] Uniwersytetu Mikolaja Kopern Toruniu, Torun, Poland
来源
STUDIA PRAWNICZE KUL | 2022年 / 03期
关键词
pestilence; epidemic; force majeure; vis maior; casus maior;
D O I
10.31743/sp.13135
中图分类号
D9 [法律]; DF [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
The following paper analyses juridical and non-juridical sources in search of an answer to the question of whether ancient Romans regarded plagues as force majeure (vis maior). The answer can be useful in the modern discourse on the nature of coronavirus and its legal qualification, as it provides a historical argument that a pandemic constitutes force majeure. The non-juridical sources indeed confirm that the plague was regarded as such and this view could be influenced by the conviction that the disease was sent by gods. In principle, the juridical sources, even those expressly referring to force majeure, do not tackle that issue nor mention plague as force majeure. It proves that plagues were not regarded as typical instances of force majeure in juridical reasoning. The silence of the juridical sources on this matter can be explained by the relatively narrow scope of the application of the vis maior concept. Only the rescript of Diocletian's will (testamentum pestis tempore conditum) made during the plague and issued in 290 can be seen as evidence thatpestis was regarded as casus maior.
引用
收藏
页码:137 / 153
页数:17
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] 'FORCE MAJEURE' - WAGNER,B
    FINKLE, D
    NEW YORK TIMES BOOK REVIEW, 1991, : 22 - 22
  • [22] BP declares force majeure
    不详
    CHEMICAL & ENGINEERING NEWS, 2005, 83 (34) : 14 - 14
  • [23] Equistar declares force majeure
    不详
    CHEMICAL & ENGINEERING NEWS, 1999, 77 (16) : 18 - 18
  • [24] 'FORCE MAJEURE' - JOLIVET,P
    SINEUX, M
    POSITIF, 1989, (339): : 62 - 63
  • [25] FORCE MAJEURE IN CANADIAN LAW
    Theroux, Michael P.
    Grosse, April D.
    ALBERTA LAW REVIEW, 2011, 49 (02) : 397 - 425
  • [26] 'FORCE MAJEURE' - JOLIVET,P
    CLECH, T
    CAHIERS DU CINEMA, 1989, (418): : 56 - 57
  • [27] Force Majeure and Investment Arbitration
    Wang, Lu
    Shan, Wenhua
    ICSID REVIEW-FOREIGN INVESTMENT LAW JOURNAL, 2022, 37 (1-2) : 138 - 159
  • [28] The exteriority of Force Majeure and the sphere of control
    Gazmuri, Inigo de la Maza
    Olivares, Alvaro Vidal
    REVISTA DE DERECHO CIVIL, 2023, 10 (04): : 29 - 60
  • [29] Acrylonitrile - BASF declares force majeure
    不详
    EUROPEAN CHEMICAL NEWS, 1997, 68 (1788): : 10 - 10
  • [30] How did the Romans sail?
    Pomey, P
    HISTOIRE, 2000, : 24 - 27