DIVINATION AT ARCHAIC BRANCHIDAI-DIDYMA A CRITICAL REVIEW

被引:0
|
作者
Greaves, Alan M. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Liverpool, Sch Archaeol Class & Egyptol, Liverpool L69 7WZ, Merseyside, England
来源
HESPERIA | 2012年 / 81卷 / 02期
关键词
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
K85 [文物考古];
学科分类号
0601 ;
摘要
The oracle at Branchidai-Didyma was a major cult center in western Anatolia during the Archaic period. This article assesses the evidence for different aspects of the divinatory process used there, including divination by mantic trance and cleromancy (using astragali), and the means by which responses were delivered. The author argues that the assumption that mantic trance was used is a retrojection of the Classical Delphic model of divination, and that more direct evidence points to the use of astragali. The randomizing function of astragali could be enhanced by modification, as supported here by experimental data. Parallels are drawn to sites in Anatolia and elsewhere across the Greek world.
引用
收藏
页码:177 / 206
页数:30
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Critical review
    Roger, Philippe
    CRITIQUE, 2009, 65 (740-41) : 3 - 4
  • [22] CRITICAL REVIEW
    FRAZER, A
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGY, 1971, 75 (03) : 319 - 324
  • [23] A critical review of the literature review
    Aitken, MD
    WATER ENVIRONMENT RESEARCH, 1996, 68 (04) : 389 - 389
  • [24] A critique of "A critical review of critical power"
    Black, Matthew I.
    Simpson, Len Parker
    Goulding, Richie P.
    Spragg, James
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSIOLOGY, 2022, 122 (07) : 1745 - 1746
  • [25] Critical Management Studies: A Critical Review
    Spicer, Andre
    Alvesson, Mats
    JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES, 2025, 62 (01) : 446 - 483
  • [26] A critique of “A critical review of critical power”
    Matthew I. Black
    Len Parker Simpson
    Richie P. Goulding
    James Spragg
    European Journal of Applied Physiology, 2022, 122 : 1745 - 1746
  • [27] The critical state of the critical review article
    Glass, B
    QUARTERLY REVIEW OF BIOLOGY, 2005, 80 (02): : 175 - 178
  • [28] Romulus and Remus as twins - An archaic theme or a late piece of information? A critical response to a recent book
    Meurant, A
    REVUE DE PHILOLOGIE DE LITTERATURE ET D HISTOIRE ANCIENNES, 1997, 71 (02): : 281 - 290
  • [29] BEFORE THE MAYA: A REVIEW OF PALEOINDIAN AND ARCHAIC HUMAN SKELETONS FOUND IN THE MAYA REGION
    Wrobel, Gabriel D.
    Hoggarth, Julie A.
    Marshall, Aubree
    ANCIENT MESOAMERICA, 2021, 32 (03) : 475 - 485
  • [30] Peer Review Bias: A Critical Review
    Haffar, Samir
    Bazerbachi, Fateh
    Murad, M. Hassan
    MAYO CLINIC PROCEEDINGS, 2019, 94 (04) : 670 - 676