CA9 as a molecular marker for differential diagnosis of cystic renal tumors

Objective: CA9 is proven to be a powerful marker for clear cell renal cell carcinoma. The studies on CA9 have been limited to solid renal cell carcinomas (RCC). We have conducted a study of CA9 expression in renal cystic tumors. The purpose of the present study was to extend the utility of CA9 for cystic renal tumors. Materials and methods: Immunohistochemistry and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) were used to detect CA9 expression in cystic renal tumors. Forty-three cystic renal tumors (22 benign and 21 malignant) were included for the immunohistochemical staining. Thirty-six patients with a cystic renal mass (20 malignant and 16 benign cystic tumors) were studied to measure CA9 level in the fluid by ELISA. Sixteen cysts (9 malignant and 7 benign cysts) were subjected both to immunohistochemistry and CA9 measurement in the fluid. Results: Using immunohistochemical staining, all the benign cystic renal tumors including the 18 simple cyst and 4 benign multilocular cystic nephromas did not express CA9. All 13 cystic clear cell RCC were scored as strong staining for CA9. For 8 multilocular clear cell RCC, 7 were scored as strong staining for CA9 and the other one was negative. There was a significant difference in positive percentage (P < 0.001) between the 2 groups of malignant and benign cysts. For the 16 benign cysts, the mean concentration of CA9 in the fluid of cyst was 162 +/- 133 pg/ml (median: 0 pg/ml; range: 0-2140 pg/ml). For the 20 malignant renal cystic tumors, the mean concentration of CA9 in the fluid of cyst was 2043 +/- 62 pg/ml (median: 2,140 pg/ml; range: 1,112-2,140 pg/ml). There was a significant difference in mean concentration of CA9 between the two groups of malignant and benign cysts (P < 0.001). The presence or absence of CA9 expression measured by immunohistochemistry and ELISA test was concordant in 14 out of 16 cases (88%). Conclusions: Malignant cystic renal tumors expressed strongly CA9 while the benign renal cysts did not express CA9. CA9 can be detected in the fluid of malignant cystic renal tumors. CA9 is a promising molecular marker to differentiate the malignant cystic renal tumors from the benign cysts. (C) 2012 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.