Descartes' dogma and damage to Western psychiatry

被引:15
|
作者
Ventriglio, A. [1 ]
Bhugra, D. [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Foggia, Foggia, Italy
[2] Kings Coll London, Inst Psychiat Psychol & Neurosci, London, England
关键词
Diagnosis; history of psychiatry; models/theories of psychiatry; social and political issues;
D O I
10.1017/S2045796015000608
中图分类号
R749 [精神病学];
学科分类号
100205 ;
摘要
Rene Descartes described the concept of mind-body dualism in the 16th century. This concept has been called his error but we prefer to call it his dogma because the error was recognised much later. We studied the original writings translated by various scholars. We believe that his dogma has caused tremendous amount of damage to Western psychiatry. This dualism has created boundaries between mind and body but as we know they are inextricably interlinked and influence each other. This has affected clinical practice and has increased the dichotomy between psychiatric services and the physical health care services in the West at least. This dualism has also contributed to stigma against mental illness, the mentally ill and the psychiatric services. We propose that it is time to abandon this mind-body dualism and to look at the whole patient and their illness experiences as is done in some other health care systems such as Ayurveda.
引用
收藏
页码:368 / 370
页数:3
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] RUSSIAN SOVIET AND WESTERN PSYCHIATRY - CALLOWAY,P
    POSTEL, J
    EVOLUTION PSYCHIATRIQUE, 1995, 60 (01): : 181 - 182
  • [22] Oneiroid syndrome: A concept of use for western psychiatry
    Kaptsan, A
    Miodownick, C
    Lerner, V
    ISRAEL JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRY AND RELATED SCIENCES, 2000, 37 (04): : 278 - 285
  • [23] SOCIAL-PSYCHIATRY IN WESTERN-EUROPE
    ACHTE, K
    MENTAL HEALTH AND SOCIETY, 1974, 1 (3-4) : 162 - 186
  • [24] STYLISTIC DOGMA VS SEISMIC RESISTANCE + BUILDING DAMAGE DURING ALGERIAN EARTHQUAKE
    WANG, ML
    AIA JOURNAL-AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS, 1981, 70 (13): : 59 - 63
  • [25] COMMENTARY ON PSYCHIATRY AND FAMILY-LAW IN WESTERN AUSTRALIA
    DICKEY, A
    AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRY, 1982, 16 (02): : 67 - 70
  • [26] ROLE OF PSYCHIATRY IN WESTERN EUROPEAN MEDICAL-EDUCATION
    HAWKINS, DR
    HAWKINS, EW
    JOURNAL OF MEDICAL EDUCATION, 1979, 54 (05): : 408 - 415
  • [27] NATIVE AND WESTERN HEALING - DILEMMA OF EAST AFRICAN PSYCHIATRY
    OTSYULA, W
    JOURNAL OF NERVOUS AND MENTAL DISEASE, 1973, 156 (05) : 297 - 299
  • [28] PSYCHIATRY AND FAMILY-LAW IN WESTERN-AUSTRALIA
    QUADRIO, C
    AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRY, 1981, 15 (01): : 19 - 22
  • [29] PRESENT SITUATION OF CHILD AND JUVENILE PSYCHIATRY IN WESTERN GERMANY
    ALBRECHT, H
    ACTA PAEDOPSYCHIATRICA, 1966, 33 (08) : 258 - 261
  • [30] CONSULTATION-LIAISON PSYCHIATRY IN WESTERN-EUROPE
    MAYOU, R
    HUYSE, F
    VANMOFFAERT, M
    RAZAVI, D
    PELC, I
    LOLDRUP, D
    BECH, P
    TIENARI, P
    GUILLIBERT, E
    MARX, G
    HERZOG, T
    WIRSCHING, M
    RIGATELLI, M
    HUYSE, FJ
    HENGEVELD, MW
    MALT, UF
    REFNIN, IB
    LOPES, RG
    CRESPO, MD
    LOBO, A
    PERSSON, T
    RADANOV, BP
    ZUMBRUNNEN, R
    CREED, F
    LLOYD, G
    MAYOU, RA
    GENERAL HOSPITAL PSYCHIATRY, 1991, 13 (03) : 188 - 208