Board composition and earnings management in Canada

This study contributes to the literature on the role of the board by investigating the effect of board composition on the practice of earnings management in Canada. We find that earnings are managed upward to avoid reporting losses and earnings declines. While outside directors, as a whole, do not reduce abnormal accruals, directors from financial intermediaries reduce earnings management, and the board representation of active institutional shareholders reduces it further. We do not find that monitoring of abnormal accruals by outside directors, as a whole, or by directors from financial institutions is more effective after the issuance of the Toronto Stock Exchange's Corporate Governance Guidelines of 1994. Finally, we do not find that earnings management decreases with the average tenure of outside directors as board members of the firm, either. Our findings suggest that adding outside directors to the board may not achieve improvement in governance practices by itself, especially in jurisdictions where ownership is highly concentrated and the outside directors' labor market may not be well developed. (C) 2003 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.