Methodological confusions in universal grammar: Reply to Kim

被引：0
|
作者：
Lin, Francis Y. [1 ]
机构：
[1] Beijing Int Studies Univ, Sch English, Beijing 10024, Peoples R China
来源：
LINGUA | 2019年 / 222卷
关键词：
Universal grammar; Research method; Causal factor; Natural law; Scientific theory;
D O I：
10.1016/j.lingua.2019.02.008
中图分类号：
H0 [语言学];
学科分类号：
030303 ; 0501 ; 050102 ;
摘要：
Kim (2018) argues that the method adopted in universal grammar (UG) is the same as that employed in the empirical sciences such as physics, chemistry and biology, and that my rejection of UG in Lin (2017a) amounts to a rejection of these sciences. In this reply I show that Kim has misunderstood the main point of my original paper, which is that UG is crucially different from typical scientific theories in that it does not consider causal factors. I further show that once this misunderstanding is cleared his objections can be dissolved smoothly, that the fatal problem with UG will become more evident, and that the methodological confusions embedded in Kim's arguments will be dispelled. (C) 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码：74 / 79
页数：6
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Choi and Kim reply
    Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering Department, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095, United States
    [J]. Phys Rev Lett, 2006, 10
  • [22] In Reply to Chang and Kim
    Bazan, Jose G.
    Healy, Erin
    Jhawar, Sachin R.
    Beyer, Sasha
    White, Julia R.
    [J]. International Journal of Radiation Oncology Biology Physics, 2023, 117 (02): : 519 - 520
  • [23] CRITICISM OF UNIVERSAL GRAMMAR
    Casas Navarro, Raymundo
    Montoya Samame, Jaime
    [J]. ATENEA, 2018, (517): : 105 - 122
  • [24] Is There a Universal Grammar of Justice?
    Culp, Julian
    [J]. PHILOSOPHY AND PUBLIC ISSUES, 2019, 9 (03): : 145 - 175
  • [25] The Universal Grammar of Evolution
    Tanghe, Koen
    Billiard, Sylvain
    [J]. PHILOSOPHY AND COSMOLOGY-FILOSOFIYA I KOSMOLOGIYA, 2022, 29 : 4 - 16
  • [26] Malagasy and universal grammar
    Randriamasimanana, C
    [J]. SEVENTH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON AUSTRONESIAN LINGUISTICS, 1997, : 483 - 495
  • [27] Meaning and universal grammar
    Lander, YA
    [J]. STUDIES IN LANGUAGE, 2005, 29 (02): : 463 - 476
  • [28] The universal grammar of reading
    Perfetti, CA
    [J]. SCIENTIFIC STUDIES OF READING, 2003, 7 (01) : 3 - 24
  • [29] The Philosophy of Universal Grammar
    Collins, John
    [J]. MIND, 2015, 124 (493) : 342 - 347
  • [30] Evolution of universal grammar
    Nowak, MA
    Komarova, NL
    Niyogi, P
    [J]. SCIENCE, 2001, 291 (5501) : 114 - 118
12345