Sport and Team Differences on Baseline Measures of Sport-Related Concussion

被引:26
|
作者
Zimmer, Adam [1 ]
Piecora, Kyle [1 ]
Schuster, Danielle [1 ]
Webbe, Frank [1 ]
机构
[1] Florida Inst Technol, Sch Psychol, Melbourne, FL 32901 USA
关键词
traumatic brain injuries; baseline assessment; Concussion Resolution Index; Standardized Assessment of Concussion; Balance Error Scoring System; NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL TEST PROTOCOL; ERROR SCORING SYSTEM; POSTURAL STABILITY; BALANCE; MANAGEMENT; SYMPTOMS; RELIABILITY; DIAGNOSIS; ATHLETE; INJURY;
D O I
10.4085/1062-6050-48.5.06
中图分类号
G8 [体育];
学科分类号
04 ; 0403 ;
摘要
Context: With the advent of the National Collegiate Athletic Association's (NCAA's) mandating the presence and practice of concussion-management plans in collegiate athletic programs, institutions will consider potential approaches for concussion management, including both baseline and normative comparison approaches. Objective: To examine sport and team differences in baseline performance on a computer-based neurocognitive measure and 2 standard sideline measures of cognition and balance and to determine the potential effect of premorbid factors sex and height on baseline performance. Design: Cross-sectional study. Setting: University laboratory. Patients or Other Participants: A total of 437 NCAA Division II student-athletes (males = 273, females = 164; age = 19.61 +/- 1.64 years, height = 69.89 +/- 4.04 inches [177.52 +/- 10.26 cm]) were recruited during mandatory preseason testing conducted in a concussion-management program. Main Outcome Measure(s): The computerized Concussion Resolution Index (CRI), the Standardized Assessment of Concussion (Form A; SAC), and the Balance Error Scoring System (BESS). Results: Players on the men's basketball team tended to perform worse on the baseline measures, whereas soccer players tended to perform better. We found a difference in total BESS scores between these sports (P = .002). We saw a difference between sports on the hard-surface portion of the BESS (F-6,F-347 = 3.33, P = .003, eta(2)(p) = 0.05). No sport, team, or sex differences were found with SAC scores (P > .05). We noted differences between sports and teams in the CRI indices, with basketball, particularly the men's team, performing worse than soccer (P < .001) and softball/baseball (P = .03). When sex and height were considered as possible sources of variation in BESS and CRI team or sport differences, height was a covariate for the team (F-1,F-385 = 5.109, P = .02, eta(2)(p) = 0.013) and sport (F1,326 = 11.212, P = .001, eta(2)(p) = 0.033) analyses, but the interaction of sex and sport on CRI indices was not significant in any test (P > .05). Conclusions: Given that differences in neurocognitive functioning and performance among sports and teams exist, the comparison of posttraumatic and baseline assessment may lead to more accurate diagnoses of concussion and safer return-to- participation decision making than the use of normative comparisons.
引用
收藏
页码:659 / 667
页数:9
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Sport-related concussion in pediatric athletes
    Purcell, Laura
    Carson, James
    CLINICAL PEDIATRICS, 2008, 47 (02) : 106 - 113
  • [22] Sport-Related Concussion in Para Athletes
    Smetana, Racheal M.
    Kaplan, Danielle T.
    Magill, Robbie T.
    Denton, Andrea H.
    Ahmed, Osman Hassan
    Broshek, Donna K.
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL MEDICINE & REHABILITATION, 2024, 103 (09) : 858 - 865
  • [23] Effects of sport-related concussion on sleep
    Gosselin, N
    Lassonde, M
    Adam, B
    Montplaisir, J
    SLEEP, 2004, 27 : 328 - 328
  • [24] Multimodal Assessment of Sport-Related Concussion
    Sherry, Natalie Sandel
    Fazio-Sumrok, Vanessa
    Sufrinko, Alicia
    Collins, Michael W.
    Kontos, Anthony P.
    CLINICAL JOURNAL OF SPORT MEDICINE, 2021, 31 (03): : 244 - 249
  • [25] The biomechanics and pathomechanics of sport-related concussion
    Guskiewicz, Kevin M.
    Mihalik, Jason P.
    FOUNDATIONS OF SPORT-RELATED BRAIN INJURIES, 2006, : 65 - +
  • [26] Structural neuroimaging in sport-related concussion
    Bigler, Erin D.
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PSYCHOPHYSIOLOGY, 2018, 132 : 105 - 123
  • [27] Management and Prevention of Sport-Related Concussion
    Hanson, Emily
    Stracciolini, Andrea
    Mannix, Rebekah
    Meehan, William P., III
    CLINICAL PEDIATRICS, 2014, 53 (13) : 1221 - 1230
  • [28] The Role of Neuroimaging in Sport-Related Concussion
    Prabhu, Sanjay P.
    CLINICS IN SPORTS MEDICINE, 2011, 30 (01) : 103 - +
  • [29] Neuropsychological Assessment of Sport-Related Concussion
    Jennings, Sabrina
    Collins, Michael W.
    Taylor, Alex M.
    CLINICS IN SPORTS MEDICINE, 2021, 40 (01) : 81 - 91
  • [30] Neuropsychological Screening of Sport-Related Concussion
    McCrea, Michael A.
    Asken, Breton
    Nelson, Lindsay D.
    NEUROLOGIC CLINICS, 2017, 35 (03) : 487 - +