Counterfactual thinking: an fMRI study on changing the past for a better future

被引:100
|
作者
Van Hoeck, Nicole [1 ]
Ma, Ning [1 ]
Ampe, Lisa [1 ]
Baetens, Kris [1 ]
Vandekerckhove, Marie [1 ]
Van Overwalle, Frank [1 ]
机构
[1] Vrije Univ Brussel, Dept Psychol, B-1050 Brussels, Belgium
关键词
fMRI; counterfactual thinking; episodic memory; CONSTRUCTIVE EPISODIC SIMULATION; MEDIAL FRONTAL-CORTEX; ORBITOFRONTAL CORTEX; CINGULATE CORTEX; MEMORY; REGRET; BRAIN; REPRESENTATIONS; EVENTS; REWARD;
D O I
10.1093/scan/nss031
中图分类号
Q189 [神经科学];
学科分类号
071006 ;
摘要
Recent studies suggest that a brain network mainly associated with episodic memory has a more general function in imagining oneself in another time, place or perspective (e.g. episodic future thought, theory of mind, default mode). If this is true, counterfactual thinking (e.g. 'If I had left the office earlier, I wouldn't have missed my train.') should also activate this network. Present functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) study explores the common and distinct neural activity of counterfactual and episodic thinking by directly comparing the imagining of upward counterfactuals (creating better outcomes for negative past events) with the re-experiencing of negative past events and the imagining of positive future events. Results confirm that episodic and counterfactual thinking share a common brain network, involving a core memory network (hippocampal area, temporal lobes, midline, and lateral parietal lobes) and prefrontal areas that might be related to mentalizing (medial prefrontal cortex) and performance monitoring (right prefrontal cortex). In contrast to episodic past and future thinking, counterfactual thinking recruits some of these areas more strongly and extensively, and additionally activates the bilateral inferior parietal lobe and posterior medial frontal cortex. We discuss these findings in view of recent fMRI evidence on the working of episodic memory and theory of mind.
引用
收藏
页码:556 / 564
页数:9
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] The Shorter Is Better movement: past, present, future
    Spellberg, Brad
    Rice, Louis B.
    CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND INFECTION, 2023, 29 (02) : 141 - 142
  • [42] REMEMBERING THE PAST AND LOOKING FORWARD TO A BETTER FUTURE
    RADHAKRISHNA, BP
    JOURNAL OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF INDIA, 1991, 38 (03) : 227 - 229
  • [43] OMNIBUS BILL - BITTER PAST - BETTER FUTURE
    STEIGER, WA
    ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL AND SAFETY MANAGEMENT, 1971, 141 (06): : 11 - &
  • [44] Motor Neuroscience: Changing the Future and Remembering the Past
    Miall, Chris
    CURRENT BIOLOGY, 2015, 25 (03) : R106 - R108
  • [45] Counterfactuals in action: An fMRI study of counterfactual sentences describing physical effort
    Urrutia, Mabel
    Gennari, Silvia P.
    de Vega, Manuel
    NEUROPSYCHOLOGIA, 2012, 50 (14) : 3663 - 3672
  • [46] Improving the Past and the Future: A Temporal Asymmetry in Hypothetical Thinking
    Ferrante, Donatella
    Girotto, Vittorio
    Straga, Marta
    Walsh, Clare
    JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-GENERAL, 2013, 142 (01) : 23 - 27
  • [47] EMPIRICAL STUDIES OF DESIGN THINKING: PAST, PRESENT, FUTURE
    Cagan, Jonathan
    Dinar, Mahmoud
    Shah, Jami J.
    Leifer, Larry
    Linsey, Julie
    Smith, Steven M.
    Vargas-Hernandez, Noe
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE ASME INTERNATIONAL DESIGN ENGINEERING TECHNICAL CONFERENCES AND COMPUTERS AND INFORMATION IN ENGINEERING CONFERENCE, 2013, VOL 5, 2014,
  • [48] Systemizing Entrepreneurial Metacognition: Thinking About the Past and Future
    Bastian, Bob
    Hjelle, Mariel
    Shepherd, Dean
    ENTREPRENEURSHIP THEORY AND PRACTICE, 2025,
  • [49] Looking on the past, thinking of the future Conversation with Paul Rainsberry
    Lemire, Francine
    CANADIAN FAMILY PHYSICIAN, 2013, 59 (10) : 1132 - 1132
  • [50] Revising the past (while thinking in the future perfect tense)
    Gioia, DA
    Corley, KG
    Fabbri, T
    JOURNAL OF ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE MANAGEMENT, 2002, 15 (06) : 622 - 634