In Search of Value Added in the Case of Complex School Effects

被引:5
|
作者
Timmermans, Anneke C. [1 ]
Snijders, Tom A. B. [2 ]
Bosker, Roel J. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Groningen, NL-9712 TG Groningen, Netherlands
[2] Univ Oxford, Oxford, England
关键词
school effectiveness; value added; secondary education; student mobility; multiple membership multiple classification (MMMC) models; multilevel chained equations imputation; PUPIL MOBILITY; ACHIEVEMENT; PERFORMANCE; SECONDARY; CLASSIFICATION; PROGRESS; MODEL; TERM;
D O I
10.1177/0013164412460392
中图分类号
G44 [教育心理学];
学科分类号
0402 ; 040202 ;
摘要
In traditional studies on value-added indicators of educational effectiveness, students are usually treated as belonging to those schools where they took their final examination. However, in practice, students sometimes attend multiple schools and therefore it is questionable whether this assumption of belonging to the last school they attended can be made. Furthermore, the schools attended earlier by students might have long-term effects on their subsequent performance. Using data from Dutch primary and secondary schools, multiple membership models and cross classification multilevel models were estimated to explore the effects of student mobility and long-term primary school effects on the estimated value added of secondary schools. Long-term effects of primary schools did not change the estimated value added of secondary schools. On the other hand, allowing students to be a member of multiple secondary schools changed the estimated effectiveness of these schools especially for schools in the middle range of effectiveness.
引用
收藏
页码:210 / 228
页数:19
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Beyond traditional school value-added models: a multilevel analysis of complex school effects in Chile
    Troncoso, Patricio
    Pampaka, Maria
    Olsen, Wendy
    SCHOOL EFFECTIVENESS AND SCHOOL IMPROVEMENT, 2016, 27 (03) : 293 - 314
  • [2] IN SEARCH OF THE VALUE ADDED
    DYSON, E
    GRAD, B
    DATAMATION, 1982, 28 (06): : 104 - &
  • [3] ASSUMPTIONS OF VALUE-ADDED MODELS FOR ESTIMATING SCHOOL EFFECTS
    Reardon, Sean F.
    Raudenbush, Stephen W.
    EDUCATION FINANCE AND POLICY, 2009, 4 (04) : 492 - 519
  • [4] VALUE-ADDED TAX - CASE FOR - VALUE-ADDED TAX - CASE AGAINST
    TERRY, A
    HARVARD BUSINESS REVIEW, 1971, 49 (02) : 31 - &
  • [5] SCHOOL EFFECTS IN THE UPPER SECONDARY SCHOOLS OF THE CITY OF MEXICO A value added study*
    Rubio, Daniela
    Farias, Mauricio
    TRIMESTRE ECONOMICO, 2013, 80 (318): : 371 - 399
  • [6] Combining multilevel analysis with national value-added data sets - a case study to explore the effects of school diversity
    Schagen, I
    Schagen, S
    BRITISH EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH JOURNAL, 2005, 31 (03) : 309 - 328
  • [7] Credible School Value-Added with Undersubscribed School Lotteries
    Angrist, Joshua
    Hull, Peter
    Pathak, Parag A.
    Walters, Christopher
    REVIEW OF ECONOMICS AND STATISTICS, 2024, 106 (01) : 1 - 19
  • [8] Is School Value Added Indicative of Principal Quality?
    Chiang, Hanley
    Lipscomb, Stephen
    Gill, Brian
    EDUCATION FINANCE AND POLICY, 2016, 11 (03) : 283 - 309
  • [9] Value-added indicators of school performance
    Meyer, RH
    IMPROVING AMERICA'S SCHOOLS: THE ROLE OF INCENTIVES, 1996, : 197 - 223
  • [10] Heterogeneity in School Value Added and the Private Premium
    Andrabi, Tahir
    Bau, Natalie
    Das, Jishnu
    Khwaja, Asim i.
    AMERICAN ECONOMIC REVIEW, 2025, 115 (01): : 147 - 182