COMPARISON OF CLINICAL INDICATORS BETWEEN FACE-TO-FACE AND VIDEOCONFERENCING PSYCHOTHERAPY: SUCCESS, ADHERENCE TO TREATMENT AND EFFICIENCY

被引:1
|
作者
Fernandez-Regueras, Diego [1 ]
Calero-Elvira, Ana [1 ,2 ]
Guerrero-Escagedo, Maria Cristina [1 ]
机构
[1] Autonomous Univ Madrid, Madrid, Spain
[2] Autonomus Univ Madrid, Fac Psicol, Madrid, Spain
来源
关键词
videoconferencing psychotherapy; face-to-face therapy; success; adherence to treatment; efficiency; COVID-19; COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL THERAPY; ECONOMIC EVALUATIONS; DEPRESSION; INTERVENTIONS; DISORDERS; DROPOUT;
D O I
10.51668/bp.8323306n
中图分类号
B849 [应用心理学];
学科分类号
040203 ;
摘要
Videoconferencing psychotherapy has been a widely used alternative in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic. This study aims to further study the success of this modality and other less studied clinical indicators, such as adherence to treatment and efficiency, compared to the face-to-face modality. Data from 174 participants, 87 of each modality were used. Both treatment modalities were successful, with no differences between them except for the percentage of therapeutic objectives achieved, which was higher in the online modality. No differences were found in adherence to treatment. Efficiency was higher in the face-to-face modality both in the treatment phase and in the therapy as a whole, but not in the assessment phase. We put forward several hypotheses to try to explain these differences, some of them related to the therapeutic relationship. The conclusions of this study open the door to future research lines in the same direction.
引用
收藏
页码:543 / 562
页数:20
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Internet Cognitive Behavioral Therapy With or Without Face-to-Face Psychotherapy: A 12-Weeks Clinical Trial of Patients With Depression
    Rauen, Katrin
    Vetter, Stefan
    Eisele, Amanda
    Biskup, Ewelina
    Delsignore, Aba
    Rufer, Michael
    Weidt, Steffi
    FRONTIERS IN DIGITAL HEALTH, 2020, 2
  • [42] Interrater Agreement Between Telerehabilitation and Face-to-Face Clinical Outcome Measurements for Total Knee Arthroplasty
    Cabana, Francois
    Boissy, Patrick
    Tousignant, Michel
    Moffet, Helene
    Corriveau, Helene
    Dumais, Rejean
    TELEMEDICINE JOURNAL AND E-HEALTH, 2010, 16 (03): : 293 - 298
  • [43] Agreement Between Telerehabilitation and Face-to-Face Clinical Outcome Assessments for Low Back Pain in Primary
    Palacin-Marin, Fuensanta
    Esteban-Moreno, Bernabe
    Olea, Nicolas
    Herrera-Viedma, Enrique
    Arroyo-Morales, Manuel
    SPINE, 2013, 38 (11) : 947 - 952
  • [44] Randomized clinical trial of telepsychiatry through videoconference versus face-to-face conventional psychiatric treatment
    De Las Cuevas, Carlos
    Arredondo, M. Teresa
    Cabrera, M. Fernanda
    Sulzenbacher, Hubert
    Meise, Ulrich
    TELEMEDICINE JOURNAL AND E-HEALTH, 2006, 12 (03): : 341 - 350
  • [45] Comparison of Preferences and Data Quality between Discrete Choice Experiments Conducted in Online and Face-to-Face Respondents
    Jiang, Ruixuan
    Pullenayegum, Eleanor
    Shaw, James W.
    Muhlbacher, Axel
    Lee, Todd A.
    Walton, Surrey
    Kohlmann, Thomas
    Norman, Richard
    Pickard, A. Simon
    MEDICAL DECISION MAKING, 2023, 43 (06) : 667 - 679
  • [46] Videoconferencing counseling online will not weaken treatment outcomes: Evidence from comparison with face-to- face counseling in-person
    Sun Qiwu
    Wang Zhihuan
    Ren Zhihong
    Yu Lixia
    Wu Caizhi
    ACTA PSYCHOLOGICA SINICA, 2023, 55 (11) : 1845 - 1858
  • [47] SyncWork: Comparison of Brain Synchrony between Agile and Face-to-Face Work Using an EEG Hyperscanning Paradigm
    Cialdini, Vincenzo
    Di Lernia, Daniele
    Riva, Giuseppe
    CYBERPSYCHOLOGY BEHAVIOR AND SOCIAL NETWORKING, 2023, 26 (07) : 572 - 574
  • [48] Low intensity treatment for clinically anxious youth: a randomised controlled comparison against face-to-face intervention
    Ronald M. Rapee
    Heidi J. Lyneham
    Viviana Wuthrich
    Mary Lou Chatterton
    Jennifer L. Hudson
    Maria Kangas
    Cathrine Mihalopoulos
    European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 2021, 30 : 1071 - 1079
  • [49] Low intensity treatment for clinically anxious youth: a randomised controlled comparison against face-to-face intervention
    Rapee, Ronald M.
    Lyneham, Heidi J.
    Wuthrich, Viviana
    Chatterton, Mary Lou
    Hudson, Jennifer L.
    Kangas, Maria
    Mihalopoulos, Cathrine
    EUROPEAN CHILD & ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY, 2021, 30 (07) : 1071 - 1079
  • [50] A multi-level Meta-Analysis Comparing the clinical Effectiveness of video-based and face-to-face Settings in Psychotherapy
    Meyer-Keirath, C.
    Kaus, M.
    Schenk, M.
    Fangradt, L. A.
    Gerdes, L.
    Buntrock, C.
    Apfelbacher, C.
    Junne, F.
    ZEITSCHRIFT FUR PSYCHOSOMATISCHE MEDIZIN UND PSYCHOTHERAPIE, 2024, 70 (02): : 151 - 152