Validation of an automated artificial intelligence system for 12-lead ECG interpretation

被引:3
|
作者
Herman, Robert [1 ,2 ,3 ,8 ]
Demolder, Anthony [3 ]
Vavrik, Boris [3 ]
Martonak, Michal [3 ]
Boza, Vladimir [3 ,4 ]
Kresnakova, Viera [3 ,5 ]
Iring, Andrej [3 ]
Palus, Timotej [3 ]
Bahyl, Jakub [3 ]
Nelis, Olivier [2 ]
Beles, Monika [2 ]
Fabbricatore, Davide [2 ]
Perl, Leor [6 ]
Bartunek, Jozef [2 ]
Hatala, Robert [7 ,9 ]
机构
[1] Univ Naples Federico II, Dept Adv Biomed Sci, Naples, Italy
[2] Cardiovasc Ctr Aalst, Aalst, Belgium
[3] Powerful Med, Bratislava, Slovakia
[4] Comenius Univ, Fac Math Phys & Informat, Bratislava, Slovakia
[5] Tech Univ Kosice, Dept Cybernet & Artificial Intelligence, Kosice, Slovakia
[6] Rabin Med Ctr, Dept Cardiol, Petah Tiqwa, Israel
[7] Natl Inst Cardiovasc Dis, Dept Arrhythmia & Pacing, Bratislava, Slovakia
[8] Univ Naples Federico II, Dept Biomed Sci, Cso Umberto I 40, I-80138 Naples, Italy
[9] Natl Inst Cardiovasc Dis, Dept Arrhythmia & Pacing, Pod Krsnouhorkou 1, Bratislava 83384, Slovakia
关键词
Artificial intelligence; Computerized electrocardiogram; Rhythm analysis; Acute coronary syndrome; Conduction abnormality; Machine learning; ELECTROCARDIOGRAM INTERPRETATION; COMPUTER; ERRORS;
D O I
10.1016/j.jelectrocard.2023.12.009
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Background: The electrocardiogram (ECG) is one of the most accessible and comprehensive diagnostic tools used to assess cardiac patients at the first point of contact. Despite advances in computerized interpretation of the electrocardiogram (CIE), its accuracy remains inferior to physicians. This study evaluated the diagnostic performance of an artificial intelligence (AI)-powered ECG system and compared its performance to current state-of -the-art CIE.Methods: An AI-powered system consisting of 6 deep neural networks (DNN) was trained on standard 12-lead ECGs to detect 20 essential diagnostic patterns (grouped into 6 categories: rhythm, acute coronary syndrome (ACS), conduction abnormalities, ectopy, chamber enlargement and axis). An independent test set of ECGs with diagnostic consensus of two expert cardiologists was used as a reference standard. AI system performance was compared to current state-of-the-art CIE. The key metrics used to compare performances were sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV), and F1 score.Results: A total of 932,711 standard 12-lead ECGs from 173,949 patients were used for AI system development. The independent test set pooled 11,932 annotated ECG labels. In all 6 diagnostic categories, the DNNs achieved high F1 scores: Rhythm 0.957, ACS 0.925, Conduction abnormalities 0.893, Ectopy 0.966, Chamber enlargement 0.972, and Axis 0.897. The diagnostic performance of DNNs surpassed state-of-the-art CIE for the 13 out of 20 essential diagnostic patterns and was non-inferior for the remaining individual diagnoses.Conclusions: Our results demonstrate the AI-powered ECG model's ability to accurately identify electrocardiographic abnormalities from the 12-lead ECG, highlighting its potential as a clinical tool for healthcare professionals.
引用
收藏
页码:147 / 154
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Validation of an artificial intelligence model for 12-lead ECG interpretation
    Demolder, A.
    Herman, R.
    Vavrik, B.
    Martonak, M.
    Boza, V.
    Herman, M.
    Palus, T.
    Kresnakova, V.
    Bahyl, J.
    Iring, A.
    Nelis, O.
    Fabbricatore, D.
    Perl, L.
    Hatala, R.
    Bartunek, J.
    [J]. EUROPEAN HEART JOURNAL, 2023, 44
  • [2] Validation of Deep Learning System for Comprehensive 12-Lead ECG Interpretation
    Herman, Robert
    Demolder, Anthony
    Vavrik, Boris
    Martonak, Michal
    Boza, Vladimir
    Fabbricatore, Davide
    Perl, Leor
    Bartunek, Jozef
    Hatala, Robert
    [J]. CIRCULATION, 2023, 148
  • [3] Automated serial ECG comparison improves computerized interpretation of 12-lead ECG
    Gregg, Richard E.
    Deluca, Daniel C.
    Chien, Cheng-hao Simon
    Helfenbein, Eric D.
    Ariet, Mario
    [J]. JOURNAL OF ELECTROCARDIOLOGY, 2012, 45 (06) : 561 - 565
  • [4] 12-Lead ECG interpretation by database comparison
    Gregg, Richard E.
    Smith, Stephen W.
    Babaeizadeh, Saeed
    [J]. JOURNAL OF ELECTROCARDIOLOGY, 2019, 57 : S79 - S85
  • [5] Artificial Intelligence-Enhanced Smartwatch ECG for Heart Failure Detection by Generating 12-Lead ECG
    Kim, K.
    Kwon, J.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF HEART AND LUNG TRANSPLANTATION, 2022, 41 (04): : S342 - S342
  • [6] A NEW 12-LEAD PEDIATRIC ECG INTERPRETATION PROGRAM
    MACFARLANE, PW
    COLEMAN, EN
    DEVINE, B
    HOUSTON, A
    MCLAUGHLIN, S
    AITCHISON, TC
    POMPHREY, EO
    [J]. JOURNAL OF ELECTROCARDIOLOGY, 1991, 23 : 76 - 81
  • [7] A Portable 12-Lead ECG Acquisition System
    Sun, Cheng
    Liao, Jingsheng
    Wang, Gang
    Li, Baopu
    Meng, Max Q-H
    [J]. 2013 IEEE INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON INFORMATION AND AUTOMATION (ICIA), 2013, : 368 - 373
  • [8] Validation of the Artificial Intelligence-Based 5-Lead 3D Vectorcardiography in Comparison to the 12-Lead ECG in a Mixed Population
    Schmidt-Lucke, Caroline
    Lischke, Betty
    Weber, Eugenia
    Gunther, Daniel
    Schomoeller, Anne
    Schmidt-Lucke, Andre
    [J]. CIRCULATION, 2023, 148
  • [9] PROSPECTIVE VALIDATION OF A 12-LEAD ECG BASED ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE MODEL FOR DETECTION OF LOW EJECTION FRACTION AMONG YOUNG WOMEN
    Garzon-Siatoya, Wendy Tatiana
    Lara, Andrea Carolina Morales
    Douglass, Erika
    Wight, Jeff
    Olutola, Ifeloluwa
    Johnson, Patrick W.
    Attia, Zachi Itzhak
    Friedman, Paul A.
    Noseworthy, Peter
    Carter, Rickey E.
    Kinaszczuk, Anja
    Adedinsewo, Demilade
    [J]. JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY, 2023, 81 (08) : 2285 - 2285
  • [10] Validation of the 3-lead tele-ECG versus the 12-lead tele-ECG and the conventional 12-lead ECG method in older people
    Antonicelli, Roberto
    Ripa, Chiara
    Abbatecola, Angela M.
    Capparuccia, Carlo A.
    Ferrara, Letizia
    Spazzafumo, Liana
    [J]. JOURNAL OF TELEMEDICINE AND TELECARE, 2012, 18 (02) : 104 - 108