Monte Carlo Evaluation of Uncertainties of UV Spectra Measured With Brewer Spectroradiometers

被引:2
|
作者
Gonzalez, C. [1 ,2 ]
Vilaplana, J. M. [1 ]
Serrano, A. [2 ]
机构
[1] Inst Nacl Tecn Aeroespacial INTA, Area Invest & Instrumentac Atmosfer, Huelva, Spain
[2] Univ Extremadura, Fac Ciencias, Dept Fis, Inst Agua Cambio Climat & Sostenibil, Badajoz, Spain
关键词
Monte Carlo; Brewer spectrometer; UV irradiance; UV uncertainty; SOLAR ULTRAVIOLET IRRADIANCE; MONITORING INSTRUMENT OMI; EL ARENOSILLO SPAIN; TOTAL OZONE; TEMPERATURE-DEPENDENCE; QUALITY-ASSURANCE; REFERENCE PLANE; OPTICAL DEPTH; RADIATION; TRENDS;
D O I
10.1029/2023JD039500
中图分类号
P4 [大气科学(气象学)];
学科分类号
0706 ; 070601 ;
摘要
Precise spectral ultraviolet (UV) measurements are needed to ensure human protection as well as to support scientific research. Quantifying the uncertainty of the UV spectra recorded is crucial to evaluate the quality of the measurements which is needed, in turn, for the assessment of their reliability. However, for double-monochromator spectroradiometers, the analytical derivation of this uncertainty is a challenging task due to the difficulties involved in propagating individual uncertainties. Under these circumstances, a Monte Carlo simulation is a reliable alternative as it does not require the calculation of partial derivatives and considers both nonlinear effects and correlations in the data. In the present study, the uncertainty of the spectral UV irradiance measured by a Brewer MKIII spectrophotometer is evaluated using a Monte Carlo approach. This instrument belongs to the National Institute of Aerospace Technology and has successfully participated in several international campaigns, which ensures its precise calibration. The average expanded uncertainty (k = 2) of the global UV irradiance measured by this instrument varies between 10% at 300 nm and 7% at 363 nm. At shorter wavelengths, it increases sharply due to thermal and electronic noise as well as wavelength misalignment. The results indicate that a Brewer spectrophotometer is suitable for climatological studies and model validation. Nevertheless, a substantial reduction of these uncertainties might be required for accurately detecting long-term UV trends. Although the study focused on a Brewer spectrometer, the methodology used for the uncertainty analysis is general and can be adapted to most UV spectroradiometers. The solar ultraviolet (UV) spectrum covers the wavelength range from 100 to 400 nm. Although it represents less than 10% of the total radiation reaching the earth's surface, it is of great importance as it can be harmful to humans, aquatic, and terrestrial ecosystems. To study its effects, high-quality measurements are needed. To determine the quality of the irradiance recorded its uncertainty must be first evaluated. Most techniques used for uncertainty estimation rely on the calculation of partial derivatives, which are difficult to obtain for most instruments measuring UV irradiance. The reason for this is that the mathematical expression relating some uncertainty sources and the measured irradiance is complex, with unknown correlations between the different uncertainty sources. To solve this problem, the Monte Carlo technique was used instead of the analytical one. The Monte Carlo approach is easier to implement and needs no calculation of partial derivatives. The method was implemented for a Brewer spectrometer, one of the preferred devices to measure UV irradiance. The results indicate that the Brewer is suitable for model validation, but a substantial reduction of its uncertainty might be needed to accurately detect spectral UV trends. A Monte Carlo technique has been implemented to obtain the uncertainty of the spectral ultraviolet recorded by a Brewer MKIII spectrometerThe methodology used for the uncertainty propagation is general and can be adapted to most spectroradiometers used in ultraviolet (UV) researchBrewer spectrometers are suitable for model and satellite validation but might be limited in the determination of spectral UV trends
引用
收藏
页数:18
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Monte Carlo-based uncertainties of surface UV estimates from models and from spectroradiometers
    Cordero, Raul R.
    Seckmeyer, Gunther
    Damiani, Alessandro
    Labbe, Fernando
    Laroze, David
    METROLOGIA, 2013, 50 (05) : L1 - L5
  • [2] Monte Carlo-based uncertainty analysis of UV array spectroradiometers
    Cordero, Raul R.
    Seckmeyer, Gunther
    Riechelmann, Stefan
    Damiani, Alessandro
    Labbe, Fernando
    METROLOGIA, 2012, 49 (06) : 745 - 755
  • [3] GEOGRAPHICAL DIFFERENCES IN THE UV MEASURED BY INTERCOMPARED SPECTRORADIOMETERS
    SECKMEYER, G
    MAYER, B
    BERNHARD, G
    MCKENZIE, RL
    JOHNSTON, PV
    KOTKAMP, M
    BOOTH, CR
    LUCAS, T
    MESTECHKINA, T
    ROY, CR
    GIES, HP
    TOMLINSON, D
    GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS, 1995, 22 (14) : 1889 - 1892
  • [4] EVALUATION OF FLICKER MEASUREMENT UNCERTAINTIES BY A MONTE CARLO METHOD
    Matthews, C.
    Clarkson, P.
    Harris, P. M.
    Ihlenfeld, W. G. Kuerten
    Wright, P. S.
    2010 CONFERENCE ON PRECISION ELECTROMAGNETIC MEASUREMENTS CPEM, 2010, : 141 - +
  • [5] Evaluation of Flicker Measurement Uncertainties by a Monte Carlo Method
    Matthews, Clare
    Clarkson, Paul
    Harris, Peter M.
    Ihlenfeld, Waldemar Guilherme Kurten
    Wright, Paul S.
    IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INSTRUMENTATION AND MEASUREMENT, 2011, 60 (07) : 2255 - 2261
  • [7] Evaluation of uncertainties in measurements by Monte Carlo simulations with an application for laserscanning
    Koch, Karl-Rudolf
    JOURNAL OF APPLIED GEODESY, 2008, 2 (02) : 67 - 77
  • [8] Evaluation of Uncertainties of ITS-90 by Monte Carlo Method
    Sopkuliak, Peter
    Palencar, Rudolf
    Palencar, Jakub
    Suroviak, Emil
    Markovic, Jaromir
    CYBERNETICS AND MATHEMATICS APPLICATIONS IN INTELLIGENT SYSTEMS, CSOC2017, VOL 2, 2017, 574 : 46 - 56
  • [9] Evaluation of Uncertainties in βeff by Means of Deterministic and Monte Carlo Methods
    Kodeli, I.
    Zwermann, W.
    NUCLEAR DATA SHEETS, 2014, 118 : 370 - 373
  • [10] Quality assessment of solar UV irradiance measured with array spectroradiometers
    Egli, Luca
    Groebner, Julian
    Huelsen, Gregor
    Bachmann, Luciano
    Blumthaler, Mario
    Dubard, Jimmy
    Khazova, Marina
    Kift, Richard
    Hoogendijk, Kees
    Serrano, Antonio
    Smedley, Andrew
    Vilaplana, Jose-Manuel
    ATMOSPHERIC MEASUREMENT TECHNIQUES, 2016, 9 (04) : 1553 - 1567