Estimating conflict losses and reporting biases

被引:6
|
作者
Radford, Benjamin J. [1 ,2 ]
Dai, Yaoyao [3 ]
Stoehr, Niklas [4 ]
Schein, Aaron [5 ]
Fernandez, Mya [2 ,3 ]
Sajid, Hanif [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ North Carolina Charlotte, Publ Policy Program, Charlotte, NC 28223 USA
[2] Univ North Carolina Charlotte, Intelligence Community Ctr Acad Excellence, Dept Polit Sci & Publ Adm, Charlotte, NC 28223 USA
[3] Univ North Carolina Charlotte, Dept Polit Sci & Publ Adm, Charlotte, NC 28223 USA
[4] Swiss Fed Inst Technol, Dept Comp Sci, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland
[5] Univ Chicago, Dept Stat, Chicago, IL 60637 USA
关键词
news bias; war; casualties; open-source data; Bayesian statistics; WAR DEATHS;
D O I
10.1073/pnas.2307372120
中图分类号
O [数理科学和化学]; P [天文学、地球科学]; Q [生物科学]; N [自然科学总论];
学科分类号
07 ; 0710 ; 09 ;
摘要
Determining the number of casualties and fatalities suffered in militarized conflicts is important for conflict measurement, forecasting, and accountability. However, given the nature of conflict, reliable statistics on casualties are rare. Countries or political actors involved in conflicts have incentives to hide or manipulate these numbers, while third parties might not have access to reliable information. For example, in the ongoing militarized conflict between Russia and Ukraine, estimates of the magnitude of losses vary wildly, sometimes across orders of magnitude. In this paper, we offer an approach for measuring casualties and fatalities given multiple reporting sources and, at the same time, accounting for the biases of those sources. We construct a dataset of 4,609 reports of military and civilian losses by both sides. We then develop a statistical model to better estimate losses for both sides given these reports. Our model accounts for different kinds of reporting biases, structural correlations between loss types, and integrates loss reports at different temporal scales. Our daily and cumulative estimates provide evidence that Russia has lost more personnel than has Ukraine and also likely suffers from a higher fatality to casualty ratio. We find that both sides likely overestimate the personnel losses suffered by their opponent and that Russian sources underestimate their own losses of personnel.
引用
收藏
页数:3
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] R&D reporting biases and their consequences
    Lev, B
    Sarath, B
    Sougiannis, T
    CONTEMPORARY ACCOUNTING RESEARCH, 2005, 22 (04) : 977 - 1026
  • [22] Reporting Biases for Hospital-acquired Infections
    Horowitz, Harold
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2013, 126 (03): : E27 - E27
  • [23] Reporting Incentives and Biases in Online Review Forums
    Jurca, Radu
    Garcin, Florent
    Talwar, Arjun
    Faltings, Boi
    ACM TRANSACTIONS ON THE WEB, 2010, 4 (02)
  • [24] Selective Knowledge: Reporting Biases in Microfinance Data
    Bauchet, Jonathan
    Morduch, Jonathan
    PERSPECTIVES ON GLOBAL DEVELOPMENT AND TECHNOLOGY, 2010, 9 (3-4) : 240 - 269
  • [25] RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ESTIMATING PRESTRESS LOSSES
    GAMBLE, WL
    FADL, AI
    GREGG, WJ
    JENNY, DP
    MALLETT, JJ
    TADROS, MK
    GHALI, A
    WORKMAN, EB
    JOURNAL PRESTRESSED CONCRETE INSTITUTE, 1976, 21 (02): : 108 - 126
  • [26] METHODS OF ESTIMATING ENSILING LOSSES
    MO, M
    FYRILEIV, E
    ACTA AGRICULTURAE SCANDINAVICA, 1979, 29 (01): : 49 - 64
  • [27] RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ESTIMATING PRESTRESS LOSSES
    不详
    JOURNAL PRESTRESSED CONCRETE INSTITUTE, 1975, 20 (04): : 43 - 75
  • [28] ESTIMATING PRESTRESS LOSSES.
    Zia, Paul
    Preston, H.Kent
    Scott, Norman L.
    Workman, Edwin B.
    Concrete International, 1979, 1 (06) : 32 - 38
  • [29] Women Reporting Conflict INTRODUCTION
    Mendes, Kaitlynn
    Silva, Kumarini
    FEMINIST MEDIA STUDIES, 2013, 13 (01) : 163 - +
  • [30] Conflict[ed] Reporting Introduction
    Ross, Christine
    Tembeck, Tamar
    Tsentas, Theodora
    PHOTOGRAPHY AND CULTURE, 2015, 8 (02) : 153 - 158