Learning from monitoring networks: Few-large vs. many-small plots and multi-scale analysis

被引:2
|
作者
Tang, Becky [1 ]
Kamakura, Renata P. [2 ]
Barnett, David T. [3 ]
Clark, James S. [2 ]
机构
[1] Middlebury Coll, Dept Math & Stat, Middlebury, VT 05753 USA
[2] Duke Univ, Nicholas Sch Environm, Durham, NC USA
[3] Battelle Mem Inst, Natl Ecol Observ Network, Boulder, CO USA
来源
基金
美国国家科学基金会; 美国国家航空航天局;
关键词
aggregation; clustering; Forest Inventory and Analysis (FIA); parameter uncertainty; prediction performance; sample design; sampling effort; SPECIES DISTRIBUTION MODELS; FOREST INVENTORY; CLIMATE-CHANGE; SPATIAL-RESOLUTION; DESIGN; ECOREGIONS; SIZE; LIFE; ERA;
D O I
10.3389/fevo.2023.1114569
中图分类号
Q14 [生态学(生物生态学)];
学科分类号
071012 ; 0713 ;
摘要
In order to learn about broad scale ecological patterns, data from large-scale surveys must allow us to either estimate the correlations between the environment and an outcome and/or accurately predict ecological patterns. An important part of data collection is the sampling effort used to collect observations, which we decompose into two quantities: the number of observations or plots (n) and the per-observation/plot effort (E; e.g., area per plot). If we want to understand the relationships between predictors and a response variable, then lower model parameter uncertainty is desirable. If the goal is to predict a response variable, then lower prediction error is preferable. We aim to learn if and when aggregating data can help attain these goals. We find that a small sample size coupled with large observation effort coupled (few large) can yield better predictions when compared to a large number of observations with low observation effort (many small). We also show that the combination of the two values (n and E), rather than one alone, has an impact on parameter uncertainty. In an application to Forest Inventory and Analysis (FIA) data, we model the tree density of selected species at various amounts of aggregation using linear regression in order to compare the findings from simulated data to real data. The application supports the theoretical findings that increasing observational effort through aggregation can lead to improved predictions, conditional on the thoughtful aggregation of the observational plots. In particular, aggregations over extremely large and variable covariate space may lead to poor prediction and high parameter uncertainty. Analyses of large-range data can improve with aggregation, with implications for both model evaluation and sampling design: testing model prediction accuracy without an underlying knowledge of the datasets and the scale at which predictor variables operate can obscure meaningful results.
引用
收藏
页数:12
相关论文
共 22 条
  • [21] Comparative effectiveness of ultrathin vs. standard strut drug-eluting stents: insights from a large-scale meta-analysis with extended follow-up
    Hassan, Ahmed
    Amin, Ahmed Mazen
    Gadelmawla, Ahmed Farid
    Mansour, Ahmed
    Mostafa, Hamed Abdelma'aboud
    Desouki, Mariam Tarek
    Naguib, Mostafa Mahmoud
    Ali, Bilal
    Siraj, Aisha
    Suppah, Mustafa
    Hakim, Diaa
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF MEDICAL RESEARCH, 2024, 29 (01)
  • [22] Holistic Small-Signal Stability Analysis for Large-Scale Inverter-Intensive Power Systems With Coupled and Full-Order Dynamics From Control Systems and Power Networks
    Ding, Lizhi
    Ouyang, Yuzhu
    Lu, Xiaonan
    Qin, Junjie
    Dong, Shuan
    Hoke, Andy
    Tan, Jin
    IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, 2025, 61 (01) : 1131 - 1147