Disability or Death: A Focused Review of Informed Consent in Pediatric Neurosurgery

The management of pediatric neurosurgical disease often requires families to choose between long-term disability and premature death. This decision-making is codified by informed consent. In practice, decision-making is heavily weighted toward intervening to pre-vent death, often with less consideration of the realities of long-term disability. We analyze long-term disability in pediatric neurosurgical disease from the perspectives of patients, fami-lies, and society. We then present a pragmatic framework and conversational approach for addressing informed consent discussions when the outcome is expected to be death or dis-ability. We performed a focused review of literature regarding informed consent in pediatric neurosurgery by searching PubMed and Google Scholar with search terms including "pediatric neurosurgery," "informed consent," and "disability." The literature was focused on patients with diagnoses including spina bifida, neuro-oncology, trauma, and hydrocephalus. Patient perspective elements were physical/mental disability, lack of autonomy, and role in community/society. The family perspective involves caregiver burden, emotional toll, and financial impact. Societal considerations include the availability of public resources for dis-abled children, large-scale financial cost, and impacts on global health. Practical conversa-tional steps with patients/caregivers include opening the discussion, information provision and acknowledgement of uncertainty, assessment of understanding and clarifying questions, decision-making, and decision maintenance, all while remaining sensitive to the emotional burden commensurate with these decisions. The "death or disability" paradigm represents a common challenge to informed consent in pediatric neurosurgery. Patient, family, and socie-tal factors that inform surrogate decisions vary and sometimes conflict. Pediatric neurosur-geons must use a comprehensive approach to address the informational and relational needs of caregivers during the informed consent process.Semin Pediatr Neurol 45:101030 (c) 2022 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.