Is a punisher always trustworthy? In-group punishment reduces trust

被引：1
|
作者：
Sun, Binghai [1 ]
Jin, Lingling [1 ]
Yue, Guoan [1 ]
Ren, Zirong [1 ]
机构：
[1] Zhejiang Normal Univ, Coll Teacher Educ, 688 Yingbin Rd, Jinhua 321004, Zhejiang, Peoples R China
来源：
CURRENT PSYCHOLOGY | 2023年 / 42卷 / 26期
关键词：
Third-party punishment; Trust; Group condition; Integrity perception; Benevolence perception; 3RD-PARTY PUNISHMENT; BEHAVIOR; DETERRENCE;
D O I：
10.1007/s12144-022-03395-2
中图分类号：
B84 [心理学];
学科分类号：
04 ; 0402 ;
摘要：
Third-party punishment (TPP) helps maintain social justice; the social preference model highlights desires to punish individuals who violate fairness and group norms. Third-party punishment affects bystanders' trust in punishers, but the effects of group factors are currently unknown. The current study assessed how the group condition between the punished and bystanders influences how third-party punishment affects bystander trust, using third-party punishment and trust game paradigms. A pre-experiment (N = 63) showed that third-party punishment affected trust between participants and the punisher. Study 1 (N = 164) showed that TPP improved trust between participants and an out-group punisher, whereas trust decreased under an in-group condition. Study 2 (N = 128) showed that increased trust was the result of increased perceived integrity of an out-group punisher by bystanders. Decreased in-group trust was the result of decreased benevolence consciousness. Third-party punishment only enhanced bystanders' trust for an out-group punisher, while the in-group condition revealed the opposite result.
引用
收藏
页码：22965 / 22975
页数：11
相关论文
共 42 条
  • [1] Is a punisher always trustworthy? In-group punishment reduces trust
    Binghai Sun
    Lingling Jin
    Guoan Yue
    Zirong Ren
    [J]. Current Psychology, 2023, 42 : 22965 - 22975
  • [2] Do Economic Crises Always Undermine Trust in Others? The Case of Generalized, Interpersonal, and In-Group Trust
    Navarro-Carrillo, Gines
    Valor-Segura, Inmaculada
    Lozano, Luis M.
    Moya, Miguel
    [J]. FRONTIERS IN PSYCHOLOGY, 2018, 9
  • [3] Punishment upon in-group defectors
    Terai, S
    Yamagishi, T
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY, 2004, 39 (5-6) : 329 - 330
  • [4] In-Group Loyalty and the Punishment of Corruption
    Solaz, Hector
    De Vries, Catherine E.
    de Geus, Roosmarijn A.
    [J]. COMPARATIVE POLITICAL STUDIES, 2019, 52 (06) : 896 - 926
  • [5] Trust and in-group favoritism in a culture of crime
    Meier, Stephan
    Pierce, Lamar
    Vaccaro, Antonino
    La Cara, Barbara
    [J]. JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC BEHAVIOR & ORGANIZATION, 2016, 132 : 78 - 92
  • [6] Impacts of trust on the cost of debt financing: The perspectives of in-group trust and out-group trust
    Wang, Yidi
    Gu, Hongmei
    [J]. FINANCE RESEARCH LETTERS, 2024, 62
  • [7] In-group and out-group social influence on punishment in unfair situations
    Wei, Zhenyu
    Ding, Yi
    Liu, Xujun
    Dai, Shiqi
    [J]. CURRENT PSYCHOLOGY, 2023, 42 (21) : 18396 - 18404
  • [8] In-group and out-group social influence on punishment in unfair situations
    Zhenyu Wei
    Yi Ding
    Xujun Liu
    Shiqi Dai
    [J]. Current Psychology, 2023, 42 : 18396 - 18404
  • [9] Identifying In-Group and Out-Group Effects in the Trust Game
    Smith, Alexander
    [J]. B E JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC ANALYSIS & POLICY, 2011, 11 (01):
  • [10] Preschoolers' in-group bias promotes altruistic sharing and reduces second-party punishment: The role of theory of mind
    Yu, Hanlu
    Hu, Xinmu
    He, Yijuan
    Li, Wenrong
    Mai, Xiaoqin
    [J]. JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL CHILD PSYCHOLOGY, 2024, 246
12345