Group schema therapy for cluster-C personality disorders: A multicentre open pilot study

被引:4
|
作者
Wibbelink, Carlijn J. M. [1 ,14 ]
Venhuizen, Anne-Sophie S. M. [1 ]
Grasman, Raoul P. P. P. [2 ]
Bachrach, Nathan [3 ,4 ]
van den Hengel, Charlotte [1 ]
Hudepohl, Sandy [5 ]
Kunst, Liselotte [6 ,7 ]
de Lange, Hinde [8 ]
Louter, Mark A. [9 ]
Matthijssen, Suzy J. M. A. [10 ]
Schaling, Arita [11 ]
Walhout, Simone [12 ]
Wichers, Karen [13 ]
Arntz, Arnoud [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Amsterdam, Dept Clin Psychol, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[2] Univ Amsterdam, Dept Psychol Methods, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[3] Tilburg Univ, Dept Med & Clin Psychol, Tilburg, Netherlands
[4] GGZ Oost Brabant Helmond, Helmond, Netherlands
[5] PsyQ Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[6] PsyQ Haarlem, Haarlem, Netherlands
[7] NPI, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[8] Emergis, Kloetinge, Netherlands
[9] Viersprong Inst Studies Personal Disorders, Rotterdam, Netherlands
[10] Altrecht GGz, Altrecht Acad Anxiety Ctr, Utrecht, Netherlands
[11] Pro Persona, Ede, Netherlands
[12] GGZ Oost Brabant Oss, Oss, Netherlands
[13] IPGGZ, Veendam, Netherlands
[14] Univ Amsterdam, Dept Clin Psychol, Nieuwe Achtergracht 129-B, NL-1018 WS Amsterdam, Netherlands
关键词
avoidant; dependent and obsessive-compulsive personality disorders; cluster-C personality disorders; effectiveness; group schema therapy; pilot study; STRUCTURED CLINICAL INTERVIEW; DSM-IV; INTERRATER RELIABILITY; AXIS-II; SCID-II; AVOIDANT; PSYCHOTHERAPY; BORDERLINE; VERSION; VALIDITY;
D O I
10.1002/cpp.2903
中图分类号
B849 [应用心理学];
学科分类号
040203 ;
摘要
BackgroundGroup schema therapy (GST) is increasingly popular as a treatment for personality disorders (PDs), including Cluster-C PDs. Individual ST has proven to be effective for Cluster-C PD patients, while the evidence for GST is limited. This study aimed to investigate the effectiveness of GST for Cluster-C PD. Moreover, differences between the specific Cluster-C PDs (avoidant PD, dependent PD and obsessive-compulsive PD) were explored.MethodsA multicentre open trial was conducted, including 137 patients with a Cluster-C PD (avoidant PD: n = 107, dependent PD: n = 11 and obsessive-compulsive PD: n = 19). Patients received 30 weekly GST sessions with a maximum of 180 min of individual ST and five optional monthly booster sessions. Outcome measures including Cluster-C PD severity, general psychopathological symptoms, quality of life, functional impairment, happiness, PD-related beliefs, self-esteem, self-ideal discrepancy, schemas and schema modes were assessed at baseline until 2-year follow-up with semi-structured interviews and self-report measures. Change over time and differences between the specific Cluster-C PDs were analysed with mixed regression analyses.ResultsThe outcome measures showed significant improvements for all Cluster-C PDs, with medium to large effect sizes after 2 years. A treatment dropout rate of 11.7% was found. There were some indications for differences between the Cluster-C PDs in severity at baseline, change trajectories and effectiveness of GST.ConclusionsThis study demonstrated that GST is a promising treatment for Cluster-C PDs. The following step is a randomized controlled trial to further document the (cost-)effectiveness of GST.
引用
收藏
页码:1279 / 1302
页数:24
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [11] Design of an RCT on cost-effectiveness of group schema therapy versus individual schema therapy for patients with cluster-C personality disorder: the QUEST-CLC study protocol (vol 22, 637, 2022)
    Groot, Iuno Z.
    Venhuizen, Anne-Sophie S. M.
    Bachrach, Nathan
    Walhout, Simone
    de Moor, Bregje
    Nikkels, Kasper
    Dalmeijer, Susanne
    Maarschalkerweerd, Myrte
    van Aalderen, Joel R.
    de Lange, Hinde
    Wichers, Renske
    Hollander, Agatha Ph.
    Evers, Silvia M. A. A.
    Grasman, Raoul P. P. P.
    Arntz, Arnoud
    BMC PSYCHIATRY, 2024, 24 (01)
  • [12] Group schema therapy for personality disorders: A pilot study for implementation in acute psychiatric in-patient settings
    Nenadic, Igor
    Lamberth, Sina
    Reiss, Neele
    PSYCHIATRY RESEARCH, 2017, 253 : 9 - 12
  • [13] A Feasibility Study of Group Schema Therapy with Psychomotor Therapy for Older Adults with a Cluster B or C Personality Disorder
    van Dijk, Silvia D. M.
    Bouman, Renske
    Folmer, Ewa H.
    van Alphen, Sebastiaan P. J.
    van den Brink, Rob H. S.
    Oude Voshaar, Richard C.
    CLINICAL GERONTOLOGIST, 2022,
  • [14] A RORSCHACH STUDY OF NARCISSISM, DEFENSE, AND AGGRESSION IN BORDERLINE, NARCISSISTIC, AND CLUSTER-C PERSONALITY-DISORDERS
    HILSENROTH, MJ
    HIBBARD, SR
    NASH, MR
    HANDLER, L
    JOURNAL OF PERSONALITY ASSESSMENT, 1993, 60 (02) : 346 - 361
  • [15] TAXOMIETRIC EVIDENCE FOR THE DIMENSIONAL STRUCTURE OF CLUSTER-C, PARANOID, AND BORDERLINE PERSONALITY DISORDERS
    Arntz, Arnoud
    Bernstein, David
    Gielen, Dominique
    van Nieuwenhuyzen, Myrthe
    Penders, Krystle
    Haslam, Nick
    Ruscio, John
    JOURNAL OF PERSONALITY DISORDERS, 2009, 23 (06) : 606 - 628
  • [16] Combined group and individual schema therapy for borderline personality disorder: A pilot study
    Dickhaut, Veronique
    Arntz, Arnoud
    JOURNAL OF BEHAVIOR THERAPY AND EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHIATRY, 2014, 45 (02) : 242 - 251
  • [17] Pharmacotherapy of cluster-C disorders -: Status of empirical research and possible treatment approaches for personality disorders
    Boerner, RJ
    Kapfhammer, HP
    Möller, HJ
    PSYCHOPHARMAKOTHERAPIE, 2001, 8 (03): : 98 - 103
  • [18] Theory of Mind in Borderline and Cluster-C Personality Disorder
    Arntz, Arnoud
    Bernstein, David
    Oorschot, Margreet
    Schobre, Paul
    JOURNAL OF NERVOUS AND MENTAL DISEASE, 2009, 197 (11) : 801 - 807
  • [19] IMPACT OF CLUSTER-C PERSONALITY-DISORDERS ON OUTCOMES OF CONTRASTING BRIEF PSYCHOTHERAPIES FOR DEPRESSION
    HARDY, GE
    BARKHAM, M
    SHAPIRO, DA
    REES, A
    STILES, WB
    REYNOLDS, S
    JOURNAL OF CONSULTING AND CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY, 1995, 63 (06) : 997 - 1004
  • [20] Design of an international multicentre RCT on group schema therapy for borderline personality disorder
    Pim Wetzelaer
    Joan Farrell
    Silvia MAA Evers
    Gitta A Jacob
    Christopher W Lee
    Odette Brand
    Gerard van Breukelen
    Eva Fassbinder
    Heather Fretwell
    R Patrick Harper
    Anna Lavender
    George Lockwood
    Ioannis A Malogiannis
    Ulrich Schweiger
    Helen Startup
    Teresa Stevenson
    Gerhard Zarbock
    Arnoud Arntz
    BMC Psychiatry, 14