Gender-Affirming Care for Cisgender People

被引:10
|
作者
Schall, Theodore E.
Moses, Jacob D.
机构
基金
美国医疗保健研究与质量局;
关键词
transgender; LGBTQ plus health policy; history of medicine; gender-affirming care; bioethics; TRANSGENDER POPULATION; SURGERY;
D O I
10.1002/hast.1486
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
Gender-affirming care is almost exclusively discussed in connection with transgender medicine. However, this article argues that such care predominates among cisgender patients, people whose gender identity matches their sex assigned at birth. To advance this argument, we trace historical shifts in transgender medicine since the 1950s to identify central components of "gender-affirming care" that distinguish it from previous therapeutic models, such as "sex reassignment." Next, we sketch two historical cases-reconstructive mammoplasty and testicular implants-to show how cisgender patients offered justifications grounded in authenticity and gender affirmation that closely mirror rationales supporting gender-affirming care for transgender people. The comparison exposes significant disparities in contemporary health policy regarding care for cis and trans patients. We consider two possible objections to the analogy we draw, but ultimately argue that these disparities are rooted in "trans exceptionalism" that produces demonstrable harm..
引用
收藏
页码:15 / 24
页数:10
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Unjust Discrimination Between Cisgender and Transgender Gender-Affirming Care
    Moses, Jacob D.
    Schall, Theodore E.
    Campo-Engelstein, Lisa
    ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE, 2023, 176 (07) : 991 - +
  • [2] Seeking Gender-Affirming Care as a Future Gender-Affirming Surgeon
    Madzia, Jules
    ACADEMIC MEDICINE, 2023, 98 (12) : 1451 - 1451
  • [3] Gender-affirming care
    McDonough, Mike
    INTERNAL MEDICINE JOURNAL, 2025,
  • [4] Gatekeeping gender-affirming care is detrimental to detrans people
    Ashley, Florence
    Parsa, Neeki
    Kus, Til
    Leveille, Lee
    Schevers, Ky
    Rider, G. Nic
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF TRANSGENDER HEALTH, 2025, 26 (01) : 235 - 252
  • [5] Challenges of Gender-Affirming Care in Incarcerated Transgender People
    Malek, Rana
    Sarmiento, Mauro
    Lamos, Elizabeth
    ENDOCRINOLOGY AND METABOLISM CLINICS OF NORTH AMERICA, 2023, 52 (04) : 677 - 687
  • [6] Gender-affirming primary care
    Cosio, Ingrid
    Goldman, Lauren
    MacKenzie, Megan
    Townsend, Marria
    BRITISH COLUMBIA MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2022, 64 (01): : 20 - 22
  • [7] Gender-affirming psychiatric care
    Tellier, Pierre-Paul
    CLINICAL CHILD PSYCHOLOGY AND PSYCHIATRY, 2024, 29 (04) : 1512 - 1513
  • [8] Gender-Affirming Care in Children
    DeZure, Chandani
    PEDIATRIC ANNALS, 2023, 52 (05): : E160 - E163
  • [9] Systematic Review of Complication Rates of Gender-Affirming Procedures in the Context of Analogous Procedures in Cisgender Patients: Gender-Affirming Vaginoplasty
    Nolan, Ian T.
    Alba, Brandon E.
    Veselack, Teresa
    Toms, John A.
    Adepoju, Jubril O.
    Hardin, Skiey
    Ritz, Ethan
    Weinstein, Brielle
    Jacobs, Kristin M.
    Schechter, Loren S.
    TRANSGENDER HEALTH, 2025,
  • [10] Gender-Affirming Care & the Courts
    Cole, David
    NEW YORK REVIEW OF BOOKS, 2024, 71 (20)