Propensity-score Matched and Coarsened-exact Matched Analysis Comparing Robotic and Laparoscopic Major Hepatectomies: An International Multicenter Study of 4822 Cases

被引：15

作者：

Liu, Qu ^{[1
,2
]}

Zhang, Wanguang ^{[3
,4
]}

Zhao, Joseph J. ^{[5
]}

Syn, Nicholas L. ^{[5
]}

Cipriani, Federica ^{[6
]}

Alzoubi, Mohammad ^{[7
]}

Aghayan, Davit L. ^{[8
,9
]}

Siow, Tiing-Foong ^{[10
]}

Lim, Chetana ^{[11
]}

Scatton, Olivier ^{[11
]}

Herman, Paulo ^{[12
]}

Coelho, Fabricio Ferreira ^{[12
]}

Marino, Marco, V ^{[13
,14
]}

Mazzaferro, Vincenzo ^{[15
,16
]}

Chiow, Adrian K. H. ^{[17
]}

Sucandy, Iswanto ^{[18
]}

Ivanecz, Arpad ^{[19
]}

Choi, Sung-Hoon ^{[20
]}

Lee, Jae Hoon ^{[21
]}

Prieto, Mikel ^{[22
]}

Vivarelli, Marco ^{[23
]}

Giuliante, Felice ^{[24
]}

Dalla Valle, Bernardo ^{[25
]}

Ruzzenente, Andrea ^{[25
]}

Yong, Chee-Chien ^{[26
]}

Chen, Zewei ^{[27
]}

Yin, Mengqiu ^{[27
]}

Fondevila, Constantino ^{[28
,29
]}

Efanov, Mikhail ^{[30
]}

Morise, Zenichi ^{[31
]}

Di Benedetto, Fabrizio ^{[32
]}

Brustia, Raffaele ^{[33
]}

Dalla Valle, Raffaele ^{[34
]}

Boggi, Ugo ^{[35
]}

Geller, David ^{[36
]}

Belli, Andrea ^{[37
]}

Memeo, Riccardo ^{[38
]}

Gruttadauria, Salvatore ^{[39
,40
]}

Mejia, Alejandro ^{[41
]}

Park, James O. ^{[42
]}

Rotellar, Fernando ^{[43
,44
]}

Choi, Gi-Hong ^{[45
]}

Robles-Campos, Ricardo ^{[46
]}

Wang, Xiaoying ^{[47
]}

Sutcliffe, Robert P. ^{[48
]}

Schmelzle, Moritz ^{[49
,50
,51
,52
]}

Pratschke, Johann ^{[49
,50
,51
,52
]}

Tang, Chung-Ngai ^{[53
]}

Chong, Charing C. N. ^{[54
]}

Lee, Kit-Fai ^{[54
]}

机构：

[1] Chinese Peoples Liberat Army PLA Gen Hosp, Med Ctr 1, Beijing, Peoples R China

[2] Chinese Peoples Liberat Army PLA Gen Hosp, Med Ctr 3, Organ Transplantat Dept, Beijing, Peoples R China

[3] Huazhong Univ Sci & Technol, Tongji Hosp, Tongji Med Coll, Hepat Surg Ctr, Wuhan, Peoples R China

[4] Huazhong Univ Sci & Technol, Tongji Med Coll, Tongji Hosp, Hubei Key Lab Hepatobiliary Pancreat Dis, Wuhan, Peoples R China

[5] Natl Univ Singapore, Yong Loo Lin Sch Med, Singapore, Singapore

[6] IRCCS San Raffaele Hosp, Hepatobiliary Surg Div, Milan, Italy

[7] Fdn Poliambulanza, Dept Surg, Brescia, Italy

[8] Univ Oslo, Intervent Ctr, Oslo Univ Hosp, Inst Clin Med, Oslo, Norway

[9] Univ Oslo, Oslo Univ Hosp, Inst Clin Med, Dept HPB Surg, Oslo, Norway

[10] Far Eastern Mem Hosp, Dept Surg, Div Gen Surg, New Taipei, Taiwan

[11] Sorbonne Univ, Dept Digest HBP & Liver Transplantat, Hop Pitie Salpetriere, Paris, France

[12] Univ Sao Paulo, Dept Gastroenterol, Liver Surg Unit, Sch Med, Sao Paulo, Brazil

[13] Azienda Osped Osped Riuniti Villa Sofia Cervello, Gen Surg Dept, Palermo, Italy

[14] F Tappeiner Hosp, Gen Surg Dept, Merano, Italy

[15] Fdn IRCCS Ist Nazl Tumori Milano, HPB Surg & Liver Transplantat, Milan, Italy

[16] Univ Milan, Milan, Italy

[17] Changi Gen Hosp, Dept Surg, Hepatopancreatobiliary Unit, Singapore, Singapore

[18] AdventHlth Tampa, Digest Hlth Inst, Tampa, FL USA

[19] Univ Med Ctr Maribor, Dept Abdominal & Gen Surg, Maribor, Slovenia

[20] CHA Univ, CHA Bundang Med Ctr, Dept Gen Surg, Sch Med, Pocheon Si, South Korea

[21] Univ Ulsan, Asan Med Ctr, Dept Surg, Div Hepatobiliary & Pancreat Surg,Coll Med, Seoul, South Korea

[22] Univ Basque Country, Cruces Univ Hosp, Biocruces Bizkaia Hlth Res Inst, Hepatobiliary Surg & Liver Transplantat Unit, Bilbao, Spain

[23] Polytech Univ Marche, United Hosp Ancona, Dept Expt & Clin Med, HPB Surg & Transplantat Unit, Ancona, Italy

[24] Univ Cattolica Sacro Cuore, Fdn Policlin Univ A Gemelli, Hepatobiliary Surg Unit, IRCCS, Rome, Italy

[25] Univ Verona, GB Rossi Hosp, Dept Surg Dent Gynecol & Pediat, Gen & Hepatobiliary Surg, Verona, Italy

[26] Chang Gung Mem Hosp, Dept Surg, Kaohsiung, Taiwan

[27] Zhejiang Univ, Affiliated Jinhua Hosp, Dept Hepatobiliary Surg, Sch Med, Jinhua, Zhejiang, Peoples R China

[28] Univ Barcelona, Gen & Digest Surg, Hosp Clin, IDIBAPS CIBERehd, Barcelona, Spain

[29] Hosp Univ La Paz, CIBERehd, IdiPAZ, Gen & Digest Surg, Madrid, Spain

[30] Moscow Clin Sci Ctr, Dept Hepatopancreatobiliary Surg, Moscow, Russia

[31] Fujita Hlth Univ, Okazaki Med Ctr, Dept Surg, Sch Med, Okazaki, Aichi, Japan

[32] Univ Modena & Reggio Emilia, HPB Surg & Liver Transplant Unit, Modena, Italy

[33] Henri Mondor Hosp, AP HP, Dept Digest & Hepatobiliary & Pancreat Surg, Creteil, France

[34] Univ Parma, Dept Med & Surg, Hepatobiliary Surg Unit, Parma, Italy

[35] Univ Pisa, Div Gen & Transplant Surg, Pisa, Italy

[36] Univ Pittsburgh, Dept Surg, Div Hepatobiliary & Pancreat Surg, Med Ctr, Pittsburgh, PA USA

[37] Natl Canc Ctr IRCCS G Pascale, Dept Abdominal Oncol, Div Hepatopancreatobiliary Surg Oncol, Naples, Italy

[38] F Miulli Gen Reg Hosp, Unit Hepatopancreatc Biliary Surg, Bari, Italy

[39] Univ Pittsburgh Med Ctr Italy, Ist Ricovero & Cura Carattere Sci Ist Mediterrane, Dept Treatment & Study Abdominal Dis & Abdominal, Palermo, Italy

[40] Univ Catania, Dept Gen Surg & Med Surg Specialties, Catania, Italy

[41] Methodist Dallas Med Ctr, Liver Inst, Dallas, TX USA

[42] Univ Washington, Dept Surg, Med Ctr, Seattle, WA USA

[43] Univ Navarra, Clin Univ Navarra, HPB & Liver Transplant Unit, Dept Gen Surg, Pamplona, Spain

[44] Inst Hlth Res Navarra IdisNA, Pamplona, Spain

[45] Yonsei Univ, Severance Hosp, Dept Surg, Div Hepatopancreatobiliary Surg,Coll Med, Seoul, South Korea

[46] Clin & Univ Hosp Virgen de la Arrixaca, Dept Gen Visceral & Transplantat Surg, IMIB ARRIXACA, Murcia, Spain

[47] Fudan Univ, Zhongshan Hosp, Liver Canc Inst, Dept Liver Surg & Transplantat, Shanghai, Peoples R China

[48] Univ Hosp Birmingham NHS Fdn Trust, Dept Hepatopancreatobiliary & Liver Transplant Su, Birmingham, W Midlands, England

[49] Charite, Campus Charite Mitte, Dept Surg, Berlin, Germany

[50] Charite, Campus Virchow Klinikum, Berlin, Germany

来源：

ANNALS OF SURGERY | 2023年 / 278卷 / 06期

关键词：

laparoscopic liver resection; extended right hepatectomy; major hepatectomy; right hepatectomy; robotic liver resection; OPEN LIVER RESECTION; HEPATOCELLULAR-CARCINOMA; LEARNING-CURVES; SURGERY; CIRRHOSIS; PROPOSAL; DIFFICULTY;

D O I：

10.1097/SLA.0000000000005855

中图分类号：

R61 [外科手术学];

学科分类号：

摘要：

Objective: To compare the outcomes between robotic major hepatectomy (R-MH) and laparoscopic major hepatectomy (L-MH). Background: Robotic techniques may overcome the limitations of laparoscopic liver resection. However, it is unknown whether R-MH is superior to L-MH. Methods: This is a post hoc analysis of a multicenter database of patients undergoing R-MH or L-MH at 59 international centers from 2008 to 2021. Data on patient demographics, center experience volume, perioperative outcomes, and tumor characteristics were collected and analyzed. Both 1:1 propensity-score matched (PSM) and coarsened-exact matched (CEM) analyses were performed to minimize selection bias between both groups Results: A total of 4822 cases met the study criteria, of which 892 underwent R-MH and 3930 underwent L-MH. Both 1:1 PSM (841 R-MH vs. 841 L-MH) and CEM (237 R-MH vs. 356 L-MH) were performed. R-MH was associated with significantly less blood loss {PSM:200.0 [interquartile range (IQR):100.0, 450.0] vs 300.0 (IQR:150.0, 500.0) mL; P = 0.012; CEM:170.0 (IQR: 90.0, 400.0) vs 200.0 (IQR:100.0, 400.0) mL; P = 0.006}, lower rates of Pringle maneuver application (PSM: 47.1% vs 63.0%; P < 0.001; CEM: 54.0% vs 65.0%; P = 0.007) and open conversion (PSM: 5.1% vs 11.9%; P < 0.001; CEM: 5.5% vs 10.4%, P = 0.04) compared with L-MH. On subset analysis of 1273 patients with cirrhosis, R-MH was associated with a lower postoperative morbidity rate (PSM: 19.5% vs 29.9%; P = 0.02; CEM 10.4% vs 25.5%; P = 0.02) and shorter postoperative stay [PSM: 6.9 (IQR: 5.0, 9.0) days vs 8.0 (IQR: 6.0 11.3) days; P < 0.001; CEM 7.0 (IQR: 5.0, 9.0) days vs 7.0 (IQR: 6.0, 10.0) days; P = 0.047]. Conclusions: This international multicenter study demonstrated that R-MH was comparable to L-MH in safety and was associated with reduced blood loss, lower rates of Pringle maneuver application, and conversion to open surgery.

引用

页码：969 / 975

页数：7

共 50 条

[41] Comparison Between Minimally Invasive Right Anterior and Right Posterior Sectionectomy vs Right Hepatectomy: An International Multicenter Propensity Score-Matched and Coarsened-Exact-Matched Analysis of 1,100 Patients
Willems, Edward
D'Hondt, Mathieu
Kingham, T. Peter
Fuks, David
Choi, Gi-Hong
Syn, Nicholas L.
Sucandy, Iswanto
Marino, Marco, V
Prieto, Mikel
Chong, Charing C.
Lee, Jae Hoon
Efanov, Mikhail
Chiow, Adrian K. H.
Choi, Sung Hoon
Sutcliffe, Robert P.
Troisi, Roberto, I
Pratschke, Johann
Cheung, Tan-To
Wang, Xiaoying
Tang, Chung-Ngai
Liu, Rong
Han, Ho-Seong
Goh, Brian K. P.
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF SURGEONS, 2022, 235 (06) : 859 - 868
[42] Comparison between the difficulty of laparoscopic limited liver resections of tumors located in segment 7 versus segment 8: An international multicenter propensity-score matched study
Efanov, Mikhail
Salimgereeva, Diana
Alikhanov, Ruslan
Wu, Andrew G. R.
Geller, David
Cipriani, Federica
Aghayan, Davit L.
Fretland, Asmund Avdem
Sijberden, Jasper
Belli, Andrea
Marino, Marco V.
Mazzaferro, Vincenzo
Chiow, Adrian K. H.
Sucandy, Iswanto
Ivanecz, Arpad
Choi, Sung Hoon
Lee, Jae Hoon
Prieto, Mikel
Vivarelli, Marco
Giuliante, Felice
Ruzzenente, Andrea
Yong, Chee-Chien
Fondevila, Constantino
Rotellar, Fernando
Choi, Gi-Hong
Robless Campos, Ricardo
Wang, Xiaoying
Sutcliffe, Robert P.
Pratschke, Johann
Lai, Eric
Chong, Charing C.
D'Hondt, Mathieu
Monden, Kazuteru
Lopez-Ben, Santiago
Herman, Paulo
Di Benedetto, Fabrizio
Kingham, T. Peter
Liu, Rong
Long, Tran Cong Duy
Ferrero, Alessandro
Levi Sandri, Giovanni Battista
Cherqui, Daniel
Scatton, Olivier
Wakabayashi, Go
Troisi, Roberto I.
Cheung, Tan-To
Sugioka, Atsushi
Han, Ho-Seong
Abu Hilal, Mohammad
Soubrane, Olivier
JOURNAL OF HEPATO-BILIARY-PANCREATIC SCIENCES, 2023, 30 (02) : 177 - 191
[43] Robotic versus laparoscopic liver resection for difficult posterosuperior segments: a systematic review with a meta-analysis of propensity-score matched studies
Fabio Giannone
Gianluca Cassese
Celeste Del Basso
Mariantonietta Alagia
Marco Palucci
Federico Sangiuolo
Fabrizio Panaro
Surgical Endoscopy, 2025, 39 (1) : 64 - 76
[44] Comparison of short-term outcomes of robotic and laparoscopic transabdominal peritoneal repair for unilateral inguinal hernia: a propensity-score matched analysis
Okamoto, N.
Mineta, S.
Mishima, K.
Fujiyama, Y.
Wakabayashi, T.
Fujita, S.
Sakamoto, J.
Wakabayashi, G.
HERNIA, 2023, 27 (05) : 1131 - 1138
[45] Comparison of short-term outcomes of robotic and laparoscopic transabdominal peritoneal repair for unilateral inguinal hernia: a propensity-score matched analysis
N. Okamoto
S. Mineta
K. Mishima
Y. Fujiyama
T. Wakabayashi
S. Fujita
J. Sakamoto
G. Wakabayashi
Hernia, 2023, 27 : 1131 - 1138
[46] Laparoscopic pancreatoduodenectomy with open or laparoscopic reconstruction during the learning curve: a multicenter propensity score matched study
van Hilst, Jony
de Rooij, Thijs
van den Boezem, Peter B.
Bosscha, Koop
Busch, Olivier R.
van Duijvendijk, Peter
Festen, Sebastiaan
Gerhards, Michael F.
de Hingh, Ignace H.
Karsten, Tom M.
Kazemier, Geert
Lips, Daniel J.
Luyer, Misha D.
Nieuwenhuijs, Vincent B.
Patijn, Gijs A.
Stommel, Martijn W.
Zonderhuis, Babs M.
Daams, Freek
Besselink, Marc G.
HPB, 2019, 21 (07) : 857 - 864
[47] Surgical outcomes after laparoscopic or robotic liver resection in hepatocellular carcinoma: a propensity-score matched analysis with conventional open liver resection
Han, Dai Hoon
Choi, Sung Hoon
Park, Eun Jung
Kang, Dae Ryong
Choi, Gi Hong
Choi, Jin Sub
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ROBOTICS AND COMPUTER ASSISTED SURGERY, 2016, 12 (04): : 735 - 742
[48] Impact of introduction of an enhanced recovery protocol on the outcomes of laparoscopic liver resections: A propensity-score matched study
Chua, Darren W.
Sim, Dayna
Syn, Nicholas
Latiff, Julianah Bee Abdul
Lim, Kai-Inn
Sim, Yilin Eileen
Abdullah, Hairil Rizal
Lee, Ser Yee
Chan, Chung-Yip
Goh, Brian K. P.
SURGERY, 2022, 171 (02) : 413 - 418
[49] Laparoscopic versus open right posterior sectionectomy: an international, multicenter, propensity score-matched evaluation
Nicky van der Heijde
Francesca Ratti
Luca Aldrighetti
Andrea Benedetti Cacciaguerra
Mehmet F. Can
Mathieu D’Hondt
Fabrizio Di Benedetto
Arpad Ivanecz
Paolo Magistri
Krishna Menon
Michail Papoulas
Marco Vivarelli
Marc G. Besselink
Mohammed Abu Hilal
Surgical Endoscopy, 2021, 35 : 6139 - 6149
[50] Laparoscopic versus open right posterior sectionectomy: an international, multicenter, propensity score-matched evaluation
van der Heijde, Nicky
Ratti, Francesca
Aldrighetti, Luca
Benedetti Cacciaguerra, Andrea
Can, Mehmet F.
D'Hondt, Mathieu
Di Benedetto, Fabrizio
Ivanecz, Arpad
Magistri, Paolo
Menon, Krishna
Papoulas, Michail
Vivarelli, Marco
Besselink, Marc G.
Abu Hilal, Mohammed
SURGICAL ENDOSCOPY AND OTHER INTERVENTIONAL TECHNIQUES, 2021, 35 (11): : 6139 - 6149

← 1 2 3 4 5 →