Asymmetry of sleep electrophysiological markers in patients with focal epilepsy

Sleep can modulate epilepsy, but we still lack a precise insight into how epilepsy affects sleep. Sheybani et al. show that sleep electrophysiological activities are asymmetrically expressed in patients with focal epilepsy, contributing to a better understanding of the interaction between epilepsy and normal brain network. Sleep can modulate epileptic activities, but our knowledge of sleep perturbation by epilepsy remains sparse. Interestingly, epilepsy and sleep both present with defining electrophysiological features in the form of specific graphoelements on EEG. This raises the possibility to identify, within ongoing EEG activity, how epilepsy impacts and disrupts sleep. Here, we asked whether the presence of a lateralized epileptic focus interferes with the expression of the dominant electrophysiological hallmarks of sleep: slow oscillations, slow waves and spindles. To this aim, we conducted a cross-sectional study and analysed sleep recordings with surface EEG from 69 patients with focal epilepsy (age range at EEG: 17-61 years, 29 females, 34 left focal epilepsy). Comparing patients with left and right focal epilepsy, we assessed inter-hemispheric asymmetry of sleep slow oscillations power (delta range, 0.5-4 Hz); sleep slow wave density; amplitude, duration and slope; and spindle density, amplitude, duration as well as locking to slow oscillations. We found significantly different asymmetries in slow oscillation power (P < 0.01); slow wave amplitude (P < 0.05) and slope (P < 0.01); and spindle density (P < 0.0001) and amplitude (P < 0.05). To confirm that these population-based differences reflect actual patient-by-patient differences, we then tested whether asymmetry of sleep features can classify laterality of the epileptic focus using a decision tree and a 5-fold cross-validation. We show that classification accuracy is above chance level (accuracy of 65%, standard deviation: 5%) and significantly outperforms a classification based on a randomization of epileptic lateralization (randomization data accuracy: 50%, standard deviation 7%, unpaired t-test, P < 0.0001). Importantly, we show that classification of epileptic lateralization by the canonical epileptic biomarker, i.e. interictal epileptiform discharges, improves slightly but significantly when combined with electrophysiological hallmarks of physiological sleep (from 75% to 77%, P < 0.0001, one-way ANOVA + Sidak's multiple comparisons test). Together, we establish that epilepsy is associated with inter-hemispheric perturbation of sleep-related activities and provide an in-depth multi-dimensional profile of the main sleep electrophysiological signatures in a large cohort of patients with focal epilepsy. We provide converging evidence that the underlying epileptic process interacts with the expression of sleep markers, in addition to triggering well-known pathological activities, such as interictal epileptiform discharges.