A comparison of feature extraction capabilities of advanced UHPLC-HRMS data analysis tools in plant metabolomics

Data analysis of ultrahigh performance liquid chromatography-high resolution mass spectrometry (UHPLCHRMS) is an essential and time-consuming step in plant metabolomics and feature extraction is the fundamental step for current tools. Various methods lead to different feature extraction results in practical applications, which may puzzle users for selecting adequate data analysis tools to deal with collected data. In this work, we provide a comprehensive method evaluation for some advanced UHPLC-HRMS data analysis tools in plant metabolomics, including MS-DIAL, XCMS, MZmine, AntDAS, Progenesis QI, and Compound Discoverer. Both mixtures of standards and various complex plant matrices were specifically designed for evaluating the performances of the involved method in analyzing both targeted and untargeted metabolomics. Results indicated that AntDAS provide the most acceptable feature extraction, compound identification, and quantification results in targeted compound analysis. Concerning the complex plant dataset, both MS-DIAL and AntDAS can provide more reliable results than the others. The method comparison is maybe useful for the selection of suitable data analysis tools for users.