Perceptions of radiologists on structured reporting for cancer imaging-a survey by the European Society of Oncologic Imaging (ESOI)

被引:8
|
作者
Leithner, Doris [1 ]
Sala, Evis [2 ,3 ]
Neri, Emanuele [4 ]
Schlemmer, Heinz-Peter [5 ]
D'Anastasi, Melvin [6 ]
Weber, Michael [7 ]
Avesani, Giacomo [8 ]
Caglic, Iztok [9 ,10 ]
Caruso, Damiano [11 ]
Gabelloni, Michela [12 ]
Goh, Vicky [13 ,14 ]
Granata, Vincenza [15 ]
Kunz, Wolfgang G. [16 ]
Nougaret, Stephanie [17 ]
Russo, Luca [8 ]
Woitek, Ramona [18 ]
Mayerhoefer, Marius E. [1 ,7 ]
机构
[1] NYU, Dept Radiol, Grossman Sch Med, New York, NY 10016 USA
[2] Univ Cattolica Sacro Cuore, Dept Radiol, Rome, Italy
[3] Fdn Univ Policlin A Gemelli IRCCS, Adv Radiol Ctr, Rome, Italy
[4] Univ Pisa, Dept Translat Res, Diagnost & Intervent Radiol, Pisa, Italy
[5] German Canc Res Ctr, Dept Radiol, Heidelberg, Germany
[6] Univ Malta, Mater Dei Hosp, Med Imaging Dept, Msida, Malta
[7] Med Univ Vienna, Dept Biomed Imaging & Image Guided Therapy, Vienna, Austria
[8] Fdn Policlin Univ A Gemelli IRCCS, Dept Radiol Radiat Oncol & Hematol, Rome, Italy
[9] Addenbrookes Hosp, Dept Radiol, Cambridge, England
[10] Univ Cambridge, Cambridge, England
[11] Sapienza Univ Rome, St Andrea Univ Hosp, Dept Med Surg Sci & Translat Med, Rome, Italy
[12] Univ Pisa, Dept Translat Res, Nucl Med Unit, Pisa, Italy
[13] Kings Coll London, Sch Biomed Engn & Imaging Sci, London, England
[14] Guys & St Thomas Hosp NHS Fdn Trust, Dept Radiol, London, England
[15] Ist Nazl Tumori IRCCS Fdn Pascale IRCCS, Div Radiol, Naples, Italy
[16] Univ Hosp LMU Munich, Dept Radiol, Munich, Germany
[17] SIRIC, Dept Radiol, IRCM INSERM U1194, Montpellier, France
[18] Danube Private Univ, Res Ctr Med Image Anal & Artificial Intelligence, Krems, Austria
关键词
Medical oncology; Diagnostic imaging; Quality improvement; IMPACT; CT;
D O I
10.1007/s00330-023-10397-6
中图分类号
R8 [特种医学]; R445 [影像诊断学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100207 ; 1009 ;
摘要
Objectives To assess radiologists' current use of, and opinions on, structured reporting (SR) in oncologic imaging, and to provide recommendations for a structured report template.Materials and methods An online survey with 28 questions was sent to European Society of Oncologic Imaging (ESOI) members. The questionnaire had four main parts: (1) participant information, e.g., country, workplace, experience, and current SR use; (2) SR design, e.g., numbers of sections and fields, and template use; (3) clinical impact of SR, e.g., on report quality and length, workload, and communication with clinicians; and (4) preferences for an oncology-focused structured CT report. Data analysis comprised descriptive statistics, chi-square tests, and Spearman correlation coefficients.Results A total of 200 radiologists from 51 countries completed the survey: 57.0% currently utilized SR (57%), with a lower proportion within than outside of Europe (51.0 vs. 72.7%; p = 0.006). Among SR users, the majority observed markedly increased report quality (62.3%) and easier comparison to previous exams (53.5%), a slightly lower error rate (50.9%), and fewer calls/emails by clinicians (78.9%) due to SR. The perceived impact of SR on communication with clinicians (i.e., frequency of calls/emails) differed with radiologists' experience (p < 0.001), and experience also showed low but significant correlations with communication with clinicians (r = - 0.27, p = 0.003), report quality (r = 0.19, p = 0.043), and error rate (r = - 0.22, p = 0.016). Template use also affected the perceived impact of SR on report quality (p = 0.036).Conclusion Radiologists regard SR in oncologic imaging favorably, with perceived positive effects on report quality, error rate, comparison of serial exams, and communication with clinicians.Clinical relevance statement Radiologists believe that structured reporting in oncologic imaging improves report quality, decreases the error rate, and enables better communication with clinicians. Implementation of structured reporting in Europe is currently below the international level and needs society endorsement.
引用
收藏
页码:5120 / 5130
页数:11
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] European Society of Pediatric Radiology survey of perioperative imaging in pediatric liver transplantation: (2) intraoperative imaging
    Herrmann, Jochen
    Petit, Philippe
    Franchi-Abella, Stephanie
    Verhagen, Martijn V.
    McGuirk, Simon P.
    Dammann, Elena
    Bokkers, Reinoud P. H.
    Clapuyt, Philippe R. M.
    Deganello, Annamaria
    Tandoi, Francesco
    de Ville de Goyet, Jean
    Hebelka, Hanna
    de Lange, Charlotte
    Lozach, Cecile
    Marra, Paolo
    Mirza, Darius
    Kalicinski, Piotr
    Patsch, Janina M.
    Perucca, Giulia
    Tsiflikas, Ilias
    Renz, Diane M.
    Schweiger, Bernd
    Spada, Marco
    Toso, Seema
    Viremouneix, Loic
    Woodley, Helen
    Fischer, Lutz
    Ording-Mueller, Lil-Sofie
    Brinkert, Florian
    PEDIATRIC RADIOLOGY, 2024, 54 (02) : 269 - 275
  • [22] European Society of Pediatric Radiology survey of perioperative imaging in pediatric liver transplantation: (3) postoperative imaging
    Dammann, Elena
    Ording-Mueller, Lil-Sofie
    Franchi-Abella, Stephanie
    Verhagen, Martijn V.
    McGuirk, Simon P.
    Bokkers, Reinoud P. H.
    Clapuyt, Philippe R. M.
    Deganello, Annamaria
    Tandoi, Francesco
    de Goyet, Jean de Ville
    Hebelka, Hanna
    de Lange, Charlotte
    Lozach, Cecile
    Marra, Paolo
    Mirza, Darius
    Kalicinski, Piotr
    Patsch, Janina M.
    Perucca, Giulia
    Tsiflikas, Ilias
    Renz, Diane M.
    Schweiger, Bernd
    Spada, Marco
    Toso, Seema
    Viremouneix, Loic
    Woodley, Helen
    Fischer, Lutz
    Brinkert, Florian
    Petit, Philippe
    Herrmann, Jochen
    PEDIATRIC RADIOLOGY, 2024, 54 (02) : 276 - 284
  • [23] European Society of Pediatric Radiology survey of perioperative imaging in pediatric liver transplantation: (2) intraoperative imaging
    Jochen Herrmann
    Philippe Petit
    Stéphanie Franchi-Abella
    Martijn V. Verhagen
    Simon P. McGuirk
    Elena Dammann
    Reinoud P. H. Bokkers
    Philippe R. M. Clapuyt
    Annamaria Deganello
    Francesco Tandoi
    Jean de Ville de Goyet
    Hanna Hebelka
    Charlotte de Lange
    Cecile Lozach
    Paolo Marra
    Darius Mirza
    Piotr Kaliciński
    Janina M. Patsch
    Giulia Perucca
    Ilias Tsiflikas
    Diane M. Renz
    Bernd Schweiger
    Marco Spada
    Seema Toso
    Loïc Viremouneix
    Helen Woodley
    Lutz Fischer
    Lil-Sofie Ording-Müller
    Florian Brinkert
    Pediatric Radiology, 2024, 54 : 269 - 275
  • [24] Are Lung Imaging Reporting and Data System Categories Clear to Radiologists? A Survey of the Korean Society of Thoracic Radiology Members on Ten Difficult-to-Classify Scenarios
    Han, Dae Hee
    Goo, Jin Mo
    Chong, Semin
    Ahn, Myeong Im
    KOREAN JOURNAL OF RADIOLOGY, 2017, 18 (02) : 402 - 407
  • [25] Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the selection of chest imaging modalities and reporting systems: a survey of Italian radiologists
    Borghesi, Andrea
    Sverzellati, Nicola
    Polverosi, Roberta
    Balbi, Maurizio
    Baratella, Elisa
    Busso, Marco
    Calandriello, Lucio
    Cortese, Giancarlo
    Farchione, Alessandra
    Iezzi, Roberto
    Palmucci, Stefano
    Pulzato, Ilaria
    Rampinelli, Cristiano
    Romei, Chiara
    Valentini, Adele
    Grassi, Roberto
    Larici, Anna Rita
    RADIOLOGIA MEDICA, 2021, 126 (10): : 1258 - 1272
  • [26] Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the selection of chest imaging modalities and reporting systems: a survey of Italian radiologists
    Andrea Borghesi
    Nicola Sverzellati
    Roberta Polverosi
    Maurizio Balbi
    Elisa Baratella
    Marco Busso
    Lucio Calandriello
    Giancarlo Cortese
    Alessandra Farchione
    Roberto Iezzi
    Stefano Palmucci
    Ilaria Pulzato
    Cristiano Rampinelli
    Chiara Romei
    Adele Valentini
    Roberto Grassi
    Anna Rita Larici
    La radiologia medica, 2021, 126 : 1258 - 1272
  • [27] A survey by the European Society of Breast Imaging on the utilisation of breast MRI in clinical practice
    Paola Clauser
    Ritse Mann
    Alexandra Athanasiou
    Helmut Prosch
    Katja Pinker
    Matthias Dietzel
    Thomas H. Helbich
    Michael Fuchsjäger
    Julia Camps-Herrero
    Francesco Sardanelli
    Gabor Forrai
    Pascal A. T. Baltzer
    European Radiology, 2018, 28 : 1909 - 1918
  • [28] A survey by the European Society of Breast Imaging on the utilisation of breast MRI in clinical practice
    Clauser, Paola
    Mann, Ritse
    Athanasiou, Alexandra
    Prosch, Helmut
    Pinker, Katja
    Dietzel, Matthias
    Helbich, Thomas H.
    Fuchsjaeger, Michael
    Camps-Herrero, Julia
    Sardanelli, Francesco
    Forrai, Gabor
    Baltzer, Pascal A. T.
    EUROPEAN RADIOLOGY, 2018, 28 (05) : 1909 - 1918
  • [29] Referral guidelines for medical imaging in children: an ESR-EuroSafe Imaging survey on availability, awareness and use in clinical practice among European radiologists
    C. Granata
    G. Frija
    J. Damilakis
    S. J. Foley
    T. De Bondt
    C. M. Owens
    European Radiology, 2021, 31 : 7984 - 7991
  • [30] Referral guidelines for medical imaging in children: an ESR-EuroSafe Imaging survey on availability, awareness and use in clinical practice among European radiologists
    Granata, C.
    Frija, G.
    Damilakis, J.
    Foley, S. J.
    De Bondt, T.
    Owens, C. M.
    EUROPEAN RADIOLOGY, 2021, 31 (10) : 7984 - 7991