Writing to learn history: intertextuality in secondary school and university students in Chile

被引：0

作者：

Henriquez, Rodrigo ^{[1
]}

Luque, Daniela ^{[2
]}

Garrido, Mabelin ^{[3
]}

机构：

[1] Pontificia Univ Catolica Chile, Hist Inst, Fac Educ, Santiago, Chile

[2] Pontificia Univ Catolica, Fac Educ, Santiago, Chile

[3] Alberto Hurtado Univ, Fac Philosophy & Humanities, Santiago, Chile

来源：

HISTORICAL ENCOUNTERS-A JOURNAL OF HISTORICAL CONSCIOUSNESS HISTORICAL CULTURES AND HISTORY EDUCATION | 2023年 / 10卷 / 01期

关键词：

History Writing; Intertextuality; Secondary Education; Higher Education; DISCIPLINARY-LITERACY; MIDDLE SCHOOL; EXPLORATION; ADOLESCENTS; EXPLANATIONS; CONSTRUCTION; CURRICULUM; ARGUMENTS; KNOWLEDGE; THINKING;

D O I：

10.52289/hej10.110

中图分类号：

K [历史、地理];

学科分类号：

06 ;

摘要：

The objective of this article is to identify and compare some features of intertextuality in texts written by secondary school and university students in Chile. Employing the perspective afforded by historical literacy, academic discourse analysis, and expert-novice studies, we analyzed 17 written texts based on questions and historical evidence. The two groups were found to differ in terms of evidence usage and writing quality. Intertextual resources are much more commonly used in university-level expert writing than in secondary education. However, surprisingly, they also appeared in a significant part of the texts produced by secondary school students through elements such as paraphrasis, direct and indirect discourse, and integral and non-integral citations. These findings provide a comparative and situated perspective of historical writing across two educational levels, posing some challenges to literate practices in Historical Education and their modeling for learning.

引用

页码：144 / 158

页数：15

共 50 条

[41] US Secondary Students' Source-Based Argument Writing in History
Steiss, Jacob
Wang, Jiali
Kim, Young-Suk Grace
Olson, Carol Booth
[J]. WRITTEN COMMUNICATION, 2024, 41 (04) : 693 - 725
[42] LEARNING TO LEARN: OBSERVATIONS ON TEACHING WRITING AT UNIVERSITY
Salvatore, Eugenio
[J]. ITALIANO LINGUADUE, 2020, 12 (01)
[43] "LEARNING TO LEARN": OBSERVATIONS ON UNIVERSITY TEACHING OF WRITING
Salvatore, Eugenio
[J]. ITALIANO LINGUADUE, 2021, 13 (01)
[44] "LEARNING TO LEARN": OBSERVATIONS ON THE UNIVERSITY TEACHING OF WRITING
Salvatore, Eugenio
[J]. ITALIANO LINGUADUE, 2021, 13 (02)
[45] Beyond "Writing to Learn": Factors Influencing Students' Writing Outcomes
Jani, Jayshree S.
Mellinger, Marcela Sarmiento
[J]. JOURNAL OF SOCIAL WORK EDUCATION, 2015, 51 (01) : 136 - 152
[46] Images of science linked to labwork: A survey of secondary school and university students
Séré M.-G.
Fernandez-Gonzalez M.
Gallegos J.A.
Gonzalez-Garcia F.
De Manuel E.
Javier Perales F.
Leach J.
[J]. Research in Science Education, 2001, 31 (4) : 499 - 523
[47] The effects of Learn to Think Intervention Programme on the Creative Quality of Primary and Secondary School Students
Hu, Weiping
[J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY, 2016, 51 : 454 - 454
[48] THE FACTORS THAT INFLUENCE THE MOTIVATION TO LEARN CHEMISTRY OF UPPER- SECONDARY SCHOOL STUDENTS IN INDONESIA
Huda, Nur
Rohaeti, Eli
[J]. JOURNAL OF BALTIC SCIENCE EDUCATION, 2023, 22 (04): : 615 - 630
[49] Implementing an Equilibrium Law Teaching Sequence for Secondary School Students To Learn Chemical Equilibrium
Ghirardi, Marco
Marchetti, Fabio
Pettinari, Claudio
Regis, Alberto
Roletto, Ezio
[J]. JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL EDUCATION, 2015, 92 (06) : 1008 - 1015
[50] The Role of Literature in Developing Speaking and Writing Skills of Higher Secondary School Students
Tariq
Zainal, Zaidah Binti
[J]. ADVANCED SCIENCE LETTERS, 2017, 23 (09) : 8929 - 8933

← 1 2 3 4 5 →