The need for robust critique of arts and health research: Dance-movement therapy, girls, and depression

被引：6

作者：

Grebosz-Haring, Katarzyna ^{[1
,2
,6
]}

Thun-Hohenstein, Leonhard ^{[3
]}

Schuchter-Wiegand, Anna K. ^{[1
,2
]}

Bathke, Arne C. ^{[4
]}

Clift, Stephen ^{[5
]}

机构：

[1] Mozarteum Univ Salzburg, Paris Lodron Univ Salzburg, Interuniv Org Sci & Art, Salzburg, Austria

[2] Paris Lodron Univ Salzburg, Fac Art Hist Musicol & Dance Studies, Salzburg, Austria

[3] Paracelsus Med Univ, Salzburg, Austria

[4] Paris Lodron Univ Salzburg, Fac Artificial Intelligence & Human Interfaces, Salzburg, Austria

[5] Canterbury Christ Church Univ, Sidney De Haan Res Ctr Arts & Hlth, Canterbury, England

[6] Mozarteum Univ Salzburg, Paris Lodron Univ Salzburg, Fac Art Hist Musicol & Dance Studies, Interuniv Org Sci & Art, Bergstr 12, A-5020 Salzburg, Austria

来源：

ANNALS OF THE NEW YORK ACADEMY OF SCIENCES | 2023年 / 1525卷 / 01期

关键词：

adolescent girls; arts and health; dance-movement therapy; depression; meta-analyses; reviews; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED-TRIALS; SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS; METAANALYSIS; QUALITY; EXPLANATION;

D O I：

10.1111/nyas.15006

中图分类号：

O [数理科学和化学]; P [天文学、地球科学]; Q [生物科学]; N [自然科学总论];

学科分类号：

07 ; 0710 ; 09 ;

摘要：

We examine a highly cited randomized controlled trial on dance-movement therapy with adolescent girls with mild depression and examine its treatment in 14 evidence reviews and meta-analyses of dance research. We demonstrate substantial limitations in the trial which seriously undermine the conclusions reached regarding the effectiveness of dance movement therapy in reducing depression. We also show that the dance research reviews vary substantially in their treatment of the study. Some reviews provide a positive assessment of the study and take its findings at face value without critical commentary. Others are critical of the study, identifying significant limitations, but showing marked differences in Cochrane Risk of Bias assessments. Drawing on recent criticisms of systematic reviewing and meta-analysis, we consider how reviews can be so variable and discuss what is needed to improve the quality of primary studies, systematic reviews, and meta-analyses in the field of creative arts and health.

引用

页码：128 / 139

页数：12

共 50 条

[21] THE CHOREOGRAPHY OF OBJECT RELATIONS - ADVANCES IN DANCE-MOVEMENT THERAPY, VOL 1 - BERNSTEIN,PL, SINGER,DL
PIVNICK, BA
ARTS IN PSYCHOTHERAPY, 1985, 12 (02): : 117 - 119
[22] OVERCOMING DEPRESSION WITH DANCE MOVEMENT THERAPY: A CASE REPORT
Tavormina, Romina
Tavormina, Maurilio Giuseppe Maria
PSYCHIATRIA DANUBINA, 2018, 30 : 515 - 520
[23] Dance/movement therapy as a creative arts therapy approach in prison to the treatment of violence
Milliken, R
ARTS IN PSYCHOTHERAPY, 2002, 29 (04): : 203 - 206
[24] Exploring methods for dance/movement therapy research
Cruz, RF
ARTS IN PSYCHOTHERAPY, 2004, 31 (03): : 201 - 201
[25] The spectrum of research options in dance/movement therapy
Berrol C.F.
American Journal of Dance Therapy, 2000, 22 (1) : 29 - 46
[26] On the value of conducting dance/movement therapy research
Higgens, L
ARTS IN PSYCHOTHERAPY, 2001, 28 (03): : 191 - 195
[27] Dance/Movement Therapy (D/MT) for depression: A scoping review
Mala, Andrea
Karkou, Vicky
Meekums, Bonnie
ARTS IN PSYCHOTHERAPY, 2012, 39 (04): : 287 - 295
[28] Critique of Home Constraint-Induced Movement Therapy Trial Constraint-Induced Movement Therapy Study Prompts the Need for Further Research
Boyd, Lara A.
Walker, Marion F.
STROKE, 2016, 47 (07) : 1960 - 1961
[29] Circle dance, occupational therapy and wellbeing: the need for research
da Costa, Ana Lucia Borges
BRITISH JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY, 2012, 75 (02) : 114 - 116
[30] Dance movement therapy in oncology: a review of current research
Koch, Sabine C.
Braeuninger, Iris
ONKOLOGE, 2020, 26 (09): : 826 - 836

← 1 2 3 4 5 →