States Do Not Delineate the "Accepted Medical Standards" for Brain Death/Death by Neurologic Criteria Determination

BackgroundThe Uniform Determination of Death Act requires brain death/death by neurologic criteria (BD/DNC) determination to be in accordance with "accepted medical standards." The medical organizations responsible for delineating these guidelines are only specified statutorily in two states. State health organizations (SHOs) are composed of policy experts and medical professionals who are responsible for addressing medical, ethical, and legislative problems related to health. We sought to evaluate information publicly available on SHO websites regarding BD/DNC.MethodsFrom December 2023 to August 2024, we searched SHO (health department, medical board, medical society, and hospital association) websites for the 48 states without statutory guidance regarding what constitutes accepted medical standards for information regarding BD/DNC using the terms "brain death," "brain stem," and "determination of death." All posts related to BD/DNC were reviewed and categorized via thematic analysis.ResultsOf the 192 SHO websites searched, there were 35 from 28 states that provided information regarding BD/DNC: 14 medical societies, 12 health departments, 8 hospital associations, and 1 medical board. Of these 35 SHOs, 12 referenced the state's legal statute, 11 referenced hospital/state/model policies or guidance, 3 referenced both legal statutes and hospital/state/model policies or guidelines, 3 referenced explicit support for standardized BD/DNC guidelines, and 6 made other mention of BD/DNC. New York was the only state with an SHO that provided clear guidance regarding accepted medical standards for BD/DNC determination.ConclusionsFor most states, the accepted medical standards for BD/DNC determination are not identified on SHO websites or statutorily. This contributes to inconsistencies across hospital BD/DNC determination policies, leading to medical, ethical, and legal challenges. Delineation of the accepted medical standards for BD/DNC determination in each state could help facilitate consistency and accuracy in BD/DNC determination, prevent false positive determinations of death, and promote public trust in BD/DNC determination and the medical system overall.