Silicate and iron phosphate melt immiscibility promotes REE enrichment

A surging rare earth element (REE) demand calls for finding new REE resources. Iron oxide-apatite (IOA) deposits have substantial REE potential, but their REE enrichment mechanisms remain uncertain, hindering REE exploration. The dominant process of IOA deposit formation is also hotly debated. Here, we use novel layered piston-cylinder experiments to address these questions. Seventeen magmatic FeP-Si immiscibility experiments, across 800-1150 degrees C, and at 0.4 and 0.8 GPa, reproduced many natural textural (e.g., dendritic magnetite) and geochemical D-Ti=Fe(LFeP) -(LSi)< 1) features of IOA deposits. Magmatic-hydrothermal fluid bubbles and iron oxide-bubble pairs formed as well. The results strongly support FeP-Si immiscibility as a controlling factor in IOA deposits, although not mutually exclusive with other models. Light REE partition into FeP liquids, preferentially to heavy REE, explaining the light REE enrichment of IOA deposits. Some DLREEFeP-LSi REE values reach above 100, much higher than previously reported. Hence, any FeP rich rock that experienced magmatic Fe-Si immiscibility (e.g., IOA, nelsonites) is expected to be light REE enriched and should be considered as a REE exploration target.