Document Relevance Filtering by Natural Language Processing and Machine Learning: A Multidisciplinary Case Study of Patents

The exponential growth of patent datasets poses a significant challenge in filtering relevant documents for research and innovation. Traditional semantic search methods based on keywords often fail to capture the complexity and variability in multidisciplinary terminology, leading to inefficiencies. This study addresses the problem by systematically evaluating supervised and unsupervised machine learning (ML) techniques for document relevance filtering across five technology domains: solid-state batteries, electric vehicle chargers, connected vehicles, electric vertical takeoff and landing aircraft, and light detecting and ranging (LiDAR) sensors. The contributions include benchmarking the performance of 10 classical models. These models include extreme gradient boosting, random forest, and support vector machines; a deep artificial neural network; and three natural language processing methods: latent Dirichlet allocation, non-negative matrix factorization, and k-means clustering of a manifold-learned reduced feature dimension. Applying these methods to more than 4200 patents filtered from a database of 9.6 million patents revealed that most supervised ML models outperform the unsupervised methods. An average of seven supervised ML models achieved significantly higher precision, recall, and F1-scores across all technology domains, while unsupervised methods show variability depending on domain characteristics. These results offer a practical framework for optimizing document relevance filtering, enabling researchers and practitioners to efficiently manage large datasets and enhance innovation.