Trade-Off Between Beamforming and Macro-Diversity Gains in Distributed mMIMO

Industry and academia have been working towards the evolution from Centralized massive Multiple-Input Multiple-Output (CmMIMO) to Distributed mMIMO (DmMIMO) architectures. Instead of splitting a coverage area into many cells, each served by a single Base Station equipped with several antennas, the whole coverage area is jointly covered by several Access Points (AP) equipped with few or single antennas. Nevertheless, when choosing between deploying more APs with few or single antennas or fewer APs equipped with many antennas, one observes an inherent trade-off between the beamforming and macro-diversity gains that has not been investigated in the literature. Given a total number of antenna elements and total downlink power, under a channel model that takes into account a probability of Line-of-Sight (LoS) as a function of the distance between the User Equipments (UEs) and APs, our numerical results show that there exists a "sweet spot" on the optimal number of APs and of antenna elements per AP which is a function of the physical dimensions of the coverage area.