Background: War and forced migration expose refugees to trauma and ongoing stress, often contributing to long-term psychological consequences. Typically, trauma exposure is assessed cumulatively; yet, trauma type may better predict psychological outcomes. This study examined the differential impact of cumulative trauma and trauma subtypes (victimization, death threat, accidental/injury) on postmigration trajectories of posttraumatic stress and anxiety in refugees. Method: Seventy-seven Syrian (88.3%) and Iraqi (9.1%) adult refugees self-reported prior trauma exposure and psychological symptoms at time of arrival in the United States and 2 years post. Linear mixed-effects modeling was performed to assess for associations between trauma variables and symptom trajectories. Models using cumulative trauma as a predictor were compared to models including the three trauma subtype variables as predictors, using pseudo-R-2 values to compare variance explained between the two methods of trauma measurement. Results: Linear mixed-effects modeling indicated that prior exposure to victimization predicted progressively worsening posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms over time postmigration (b = .97, SE = .45, t = 2.14, p = .036). Cumulative trauma also predicted increasing PTSD symptoms (b = .124, SE = .06, t = 2.09, p = .041), but explained less variance than victimization (9% vs. 18.1%). Direct effects of cumulative trauma (p = .009) and victimization (p = .002) on anxiety severity emerged; however, anxiety symptoms did not change over time depending on prior trauma exposure. Accidents/injuries and death threats did not predict PTSD or anxiety. Conclusions: These findings can be leveraged toward focused identification of those at highest risk for progressive illness postmigration, thus providing empirical guidance for allocation of interventions and resources for refugees.