The effect of structural bending properties versus material bending properties on maize stalk lodging

Stalk lodging (mechanical failure of stalks or stems before harvest) is a major problem in grain production that significantly reduces yield. Efforts to improve stalk lodging are hampered by a limited understanding of the determinants of stalk failure. This study examined the structural bending properties and material bending properties of maize (Zea mays L.) stalks. First, an in-field phenotyping device known as DARLING (Device for Assessing Resistance to Lodging In Grains) was used to determine structural properties of maize stalks. Stalks were then subjected to a rind penetration protocol and morphological measurements were acquired. Finally, small strips of rind tissue were excised from the stalks and micro three-point bending tests were conducted to determine the material properties of the rind tissue. Results showed that the material bending strength of the rind tissue was approximately twice as large as the bending stresses present in the rind tissue when failure occurred during field testing. This indicates that stalks ultimately fail due to some form of buckling (i.e., structural failure) as opposed to material failure. This result is relevant to genetic and breeding studies seeking to address the problem of stalk lodging. In particular, these results suggest that improvements in stalk lodging resistance should focus on the stalk's geometric features, such as the ratio of rind thickness to diameter, rather than solely on enhancing material strength. For the samples in this study, material strength ranged between 64 and 197 MPa whereas material stiffness ranged between 4 and 12 GPa. Rind penetration resistance was found to be a good predictor of material properties but a poor predictor of structural properties.