US County-Level Variation in Availability and Prevalence of Black Physicians in 1906

IMPORTANCE Black physicians are substantially underrepresented in the US health care workforce, with detrimental effects on the health and health care experiences of Black individuals. These contemporary gaps can be traced to the early days of the medical profession using the first edition of the American Medical Directory (AMD). OBJECTIVE To identify state- and county-level patterns related to the training and availability of Black physicians relative to their White counterparts in the 1906 AMD. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS For this cross-sectional study, data for 41 828 physician entries in 18 US states in or adjacent to the South as well as the District of Columbia were extracted from the 1906 AMD and aggregated to 1570 counties. Data analysis was performed between September 2023 and January 2024. EXPOSURES County-level exposure variables included population density, racial composition, and illiteracy rate among US-born White residents as well as an index of terrain ruggedness and the number of lynchings in the previous decade. Median values of physicians' distance from place of practice to place of medical training (by race of physician) were also used as an exposure variable. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES There were 4 county-level outcomes: (1) presence of any Black physician, (2) proportion of Black physicians per Black population, (3) proportion of White physicians per White population, and (4) community representativeness (reported as the community representativeness ratio). The cross-sectional analysis used generalized additive mixed models with state-level random effects. RESULTS Across 1570 counties, Black physicians comprised 746 (1.8%) of the 41 828 physicians in the dataset. Black physicians tended to train further from their place of practice than their White counterparts. The proportion of Black physicians per 1000 Black residents was 0.08 compared with 1.62 for White physicians; these proportions varied substantially by state. At the county level, the presence of any Black physician was associated with percentage Black population (odds ratio [OR], 28.94 [95% CI, 9.77 to 85.76]; P <= .001), population density (OR, 2.63 [95% CI, 2.03 to 3.40]; P <= .001), and distance to the nearest Black medical school (OR, 0.62 [95% CI, 0.42 to 0.92]; P = .02). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE A variety of structural disadvantages are illustrated in this cross-sectional study of county-level sociodemographic and geographic characteristics associated with the prevalence of Black physicians in the earliest days of the profession. To demonstrate its broader utility for health disparities research, the dataset has been made publicly available with a visualization platform.