AMBICOREF: Evaluating Human and Model Sensitivity to Ambiguous Coreference

Given a sentence "Abby told Brittney that she upset Courtney", one would struggle to understand who "she" refers to, and ask for clarification. However, if the word "upset" were replaced with "hugged", "she" unambiguously refers to Abby. We study if modern co-reference resolution models are sensitive to such pronominal ambiguity. To this end, we construct AMBICOREF, a diagnostic corpus of minimal sentence pairs with ambiguous and unambiguous referents. Our examples generalize psycholinguistic studies of human perception of ambiguity around particular arrangements of verbs and their arguments. Analysis shows that (1) humans are less sure of referents in ambiguous AmbiCoref examples than unambiguous ones, and (2) most coreference models show little difference in output between ambiguous and unambiguous pairs. We release AMBICOREF as a diagnostic corpus for testing whether models treat ambiguity similarly to humans.(1)