Object-Oriented Ontology by Graham Harman as a Project to Overcome Correlationism

被引:0
|
作者
Devaykin, Igor A. [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Moscow MV Lomonosov State Univ, 27-4,Lomonosovsky Ave,GSP-1, Moscow 119991, Russia
[2] Moscow Tech Univ Commun & Informat, 8A Aviamotornaya Str, Moscow 111024, Russia
关键词
Graham Harman; object-oriented ontology; correlationism; philoso- phy of access; thing-in-itself;
D O I
10.21146/0042-8744-2024-4-86-96
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
The article analyzes the concept of Graham Harman, who is working on the creation of an object -oriented ontology. Harman sets himself the task of overcoming correlationism, which is understood as a type of philosophizing that defines the relationship (correlation) between man and the world as the only object of study. We must agree that the criticism of correlationism is necessary, since correlationism narrows the field of philosophical work and does not clarify the conditions of its own functioning. Harman's arguments against correlationism are discussed and the conclusion is made that OOO rightly demands the restoration of the idea of a thing as such. However, Harman absolutely incorrectly presents his concept of the "object" as a substitute for the Kantian "thing in itself". We also criticize Harman's idea of the "flat ontology" for the fact that it presupposes the existence of objects (real, fictional and created) with an equal degree of reality, due to the completely unreasonable extrapolation of human relationship with the world to all things. The result of Harman's attempt to overcome correlationism is the strengthening of correlationism. From which we conclude that the object -oriented overcoming of correlationism is completely inconsistent. A detailed analysis fails to reveal at least one clearly substantiated proposition of Harman's concept. In our opinion, correlationism cannot be overcome, but it must be fought. To do this, ontology should shift its attention to reality itself, which affects the subject in everyday life. Harman unjustifiably denies the figure of the subject, since its restoration contributes to a decrease in correlation, while the elimination of the subject, on the contrary, leads to the risk of hypertrophy of correlationism.
引用
收藏
页码:86 / 98
页数:225
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] THEORETICAL STUDY OF IMMERSION IN OBJECT-ORIENTED ONTOLOGY AND POSTHUMANISM
    Venkova, Alina V.
    VESTNIK TOMSKOGO GOSUDARSTVENNOGO UNIVERSITETA-KULTUROLOGIYA I ISKUSSTVOVEDENIE-TOMSK STATE UNIVERSITY JOURNAL OF CULTURAL STUDIES AND ART HISTORY, 2021, 44 : 5 - 13
  • [32] ABJECT WITHDRAWAL? on the prospect of a nonanthropocentric object-oriented ontology
    Booth, Robert
    ANGELAKI-JOURNAL OF THE THEORETICAL HUMANITIES, 2021, 26 (05): : 20 - 37
  • [33] STRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES OF THE ONTOLOGY OF MARKUS GABRIEL AND GRAHAM HARMAN
    Berruga, Manuel Angel Gonzalez
    SYNESIS, 2024, 16 (03):
  • [34] The Object Strikes Back: An Interview with Graham Harman
    Kimbell, Lucy
    DESIGN AND CULTURE, 2013, 5 (01) : 103 - 117
  • [35] STREAMLINING THE PROJECT CYCLE WITH OBJECT-ORIENTED REQUIREMENTS
    JORDAN, R
    SMILAN, R
    WILKINSON, A
    SIGPLAN NOTICES, 1994, 29 (10): : 287 - 300
  • [36] OBJECT-ORIENTED FUTURE MAY BE BRIGHT, IF DEVELOPERS OVERCOME PROBLEMS
    BRACKETT, J
    MINI-MICRO SYSTEMS, 1989, 22 (03): : 35 - &
  • [37] Ontology based object-oriented domain modelling: fundamental concepts
    Joerg Evermann
    Yair Wand
    Requirements Engineering, 2005, 10 : 146 - 160
  • [38] The Essences of Objects: Explicating a Theory of Essence in Object-Oriented Ontology
    Howdyshell, Stanford
    OPEN PHILOSOPHY, 2020, 3 (01) : 1 - 10
  • [39] OOC-O: A Reference Ontology on Object-Oriented Code
    de Aguiar, Camila Zacche
    Falbo, Ricardo de Almeida
    Silva Souza, Vitor E.
    CONCEPTUAL MODELING, ER 2019, 2019, 11788 : 13 - 27
  • [40] Bio-ontology construction using object-oriented paradigm
    Yang, KA
    Yang, HJ
    Yang, JD
    Kim, KH
    12th Asia-Pacific Software Engineering Conference, Proceedings, 2005, : 317 - 322