What do we know when we learn the meanings of words?

被引:0
|
作者
Scarafone, Antonio [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Reading, Reading, Berks, England
来源
关键词
Wittgenstein; Tomasello; linguistic competency; practical abilities; knowledge;
D O I
10.4396/20180205
中图分类号
H [语言、文字];
学科分类号
05 ;
摘要
In this paper I will argue that, contrary to what most scholars are inclined to believe, there are important tensions between the later Wittgenstein's views on language and Michael Tomasello's usage-based theory of language acquisition. On one hand, Wittgenstein characterises the first steps into the acquisition of a first language as a matter of acquiring practical abilities, which, in an anti-intellectualistic vein, do not require any kind of knowledge. On the other hand, Tomasello employs a Gricean model of communication to describe pre-linguistic children's communicative interactions, thus taking an intellectualist stance. According to this model, children are supposed to acquire the meanings of words because they are able to infer communicators' intentions on the basis of the common ground (mutual knowledge) they establish with them. Eliciting this tension is of uttermost importance because: (i) it bears crucial implications for the explanatory relationships between language and thought; (ii) it is central to the heart of Tomasello's project of explaining linguistic competency as based on communicative abilities. In the conclusion, I will argue that there are ways to ease the main tension if, following Richard Moore, basic communicative acts are conceived of as Minimally Gricean.
引用
收藏
页码:111 / 123
页数:13
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] WHEN WE BUY BOOKS, WE KNOW WHAT WE PAY FOR - OR DO WE
    BOISSONNAS, CM
    LIBRARY ACQUISITIONS-PRACTICE AND THEORY, 1989, 13 (02): : 87 - 101
  • [22] What we know and what we do not know
    McDonald, JC
    RADIATION PROTECTION DOSIMETRY, 2005, 113 (02) : 127 - 128
  • [23] We do not know what we do not know
    Spaeth, GL
    OPHTHALMIC SURGERY AND LASERS, 1999, 30 (05): : 337 - 340
  • [24] BIRTH ASPHYXIA AND THE NEONATAL BRAIN - WHAT DO WE KNOW AND WHEN DO WE KNOW IT
    NELSON, KB
    EMERY, ES
    CLINICS IN PERINATOLOGY, 1993, 20 (02) : 327 - 344
  • [25] DO WE REALLY KNOW WHAT WE DO WHEN WE BELIEVE WE FIGHT CRIME?
    Coronado, David
    TERRITORIOS, 2006, (15) : 33 - 52
  • [26] Cardiac Imaging in the Geriatric Population: What Do We Think We Know, and What Do We Need to Learn?
    Mehta, Nidhi
    Chokshi, Neel P.
    Kirkpatrick, James N.
    PROGRESS IN CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES, 2014, 57 (02) : 204 - 214
  • [27] WHAT DO WE KNOW WHEN WE KNOW WHAT HAVING AUDITORY EXPERIENCE IS LIKE
    NATSOULAS, T
    BEHAVIORAL AND BRAIN SCIENCES, 1978, 1 (03) : 361 - 361
  • [28] WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT UNKNOWN WORDS
    DURSO, FT
    SHORE, WJ
    BULLETIN OF THE PSYCHONOMIC SOCIETY, 1990, 28 (06) : 485 - 485
  • [29] Alpine Ecology in the Iberian Peninsula: What Do We Know, and What Do We Need to Learn?
    Barrio, Isabel C.
    Bueno, C. Guillermo
    Nagy, Laszlo
    Palacio, Sara
    Grau, Oriol
    Munilla, Ignacio
    Begona Garcia, Maria
    Garcia-Cervigon, Ana I.
    Gartzia, Maite
    Gazol, Antonio
    Lara-Romero, Carlos
    Anadon-Rosell, Alba
    Ninot, Josep M.
    Chocarro, Cristina
    Alados, Concepcion L.
    Fillat, Federico
    Zamora, Regino
    MOUNTAIN RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT, 2013, 33 (04) : 437 - 442
  • [30] We know what they think, but do we know what they do?
    Callingham, M
    Baker, T
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MARKET RESEARCH, 2002, 44 (03) : 299 - 335