COMPARISON OF THE PHOSPHATE REQUIREMENTS OF BURR MEDIC AND YELLOW SERRADELLA WITH THAT OF WHEAT IN THE LOW RAINFALL WHEAT-BELT OF WESTERN-AUSTRALIA

The responses of burr medic (Medicago polymorpha) and yellow serradella (Ornithopus compressus) to topdressed phosphate were compared with the response of wheat (Triticum aestivum) to drilled phosphate on a range of soils in the low rainfall wheatbelt of Western Australia. Species were compared firstly on the amount of applied phosphorus (P) required for 90% maximum yield at 3 harvests, and secondly on the ratio of their curvature coefficients from the Mitscherlich relationship between absolute yield and P applied. On 7 marginally acidic, medium-textured soils, the comparative requirements of burr medic (cvv. Serena or Santiago) and wheat (cv. Gutha) for applied P changed with harvest. At harvest 1 [52-55 days after sowing (DAS)], burr medic generally had a larger curvature coefficient and required less applied P for 90% maximum yield than wheat. At harvest 2 (107-111 DAS) and for harvest 3 (seed yields), the curvature coefficients for burr medic were smaller than those for wheat, and burr medic generally required more applied P at 90% maximum yield. The average P requirement at 90% maximum yield of burr medic was 14 kg P/ha at harvest 1, 22 kg P/ha at harvest 2, and 19 kg P/ha for seed production. The average P requirement of wheat was 28 kg P/ha at harvest 1, 11 kg P/ha at harvest 2, and 15 kg P/ha for seed production. On 3 acidic, light-textured soils, yellow serradella (cv. Madeira) generally had a lower requirement for applied P at 90% maximum yield, and a larger curvature coefficient, than wheat (cv. Gutha) at all harvests in each experiment. The requirements of yellow serradella and wheat also varied between harvests. The average P requirement at 90% maximum yield of yellow serradella was 16 kg P/ha at harvest 1 (52-55 DAS), 21 kg P/ha at harvest 2 (105-110 DAS), and close to 26 kg P/ha for seed production. The average P requirement of wheat was 29 kg P/ha at harvest 1, 25 kg P/ha at harvest 2, and >33 kg P/ha for seed production. In most experiments burr medic had a larger absolute response to applied P at harvests 1 and 2 and a lower absolute response for seed production than wheat. Yellow serradella had a smaller absolute yield response to applied P than wheat over all 3 harvests. When converted to a percentage of maximum yield, burr medic and yellow serradella had a lower percentage response to applied P at harvest 1, and a higher percentage response at harvest 2 and for seed production than wheat.