Employment Struggles and the Commodification of Time: Marx and the Analysis of Working Time Flexibility

This paper explores new working time arrangements around a critique of the 'commodification of time' to illuminate the contradictions of such new flexibilities. Two features of these new arrangements are seen as relevant for evaluating the Marx/Engels analysis. Firstly, it roots the examination of time in commodification, although, as criticised in this paper, some authors have seen this as the generality of time rather than that within the exchange of labour power. Significantly - and central in all working time arrangements - it is labour power that is sold, be it for a particular period of time, rather than the time itself. Hence, working time arrangements set boundaries against 'free' time or time in which labour power is not sold as a commodity, that 'free' time which was recognised in the traditional arrangements fought over in early industrialism - which set premium payments against anti-social hours within 'overtime'. New working time arrangements tend to blur the boundaries between 'free' and 'working' time, assuming an availability of labour power to capital. While much of the promotion of flexibility stresses the possibility of making adjustment to suit social and domestic requirements it is more usually the means for altering working time to meet the demands of capital. The much-vaunted case of Volkswagen has led to 'working time accounts' becoming the established temporal arrangement within the German car industry and increasingly becoming the norm for other European auto producers. The name given to these new working arrangements within the motor industry suggests that time has indeed become further commodified. For workers within these new time regimes, the hours owed to their employer is displayed along with their earnings - and deductions - on their wage slip. As indicated, such systems of flexible time were also apparent to Marx in the changes instituted by industrial capital to ameliorate the impact of the regulation imposed by the Ten-Hour Bill. He offered the metaphor of the actor on stage and in the wings which seems useful for understanding our contemporary arrangements. In practice we now must distinguish between the operational time and time in which individual workers are engaged. Previously, premium payments - of 'time and a half' and so forth recognised time as heterogeneous, as 'social time' with a value beyond exchange of labour power. The uniformity of flexible time represents a qualitative move towards a homogeneous measure of clock-time now stored in a system of exchange of time for money, allowing capital to increasingly control labour time through extending and accumulating 'time debt'.