Reconsideration of the Effects of Handwriting: Comparing Cognitive Load of Handwriting and Typing

被引:5
|
作者
Shibata, Hirohito [1 ]
Omura, Kengo [2 ]
机构
[1] Fuji Xerox Co Ltd, Res & Technol Dept, Yokohama, Kanagawa, Japan
[2] Fuji Xerox Co Ltd, Smart Work Innovat Dept, Yokohama, Kanagawa, Japan
关键词
Handwriting; Typing; Cognitive load; Dual task method; Memorization;
D O I
10.3169/mta.6.255
中图分类号
TM [电工技术]; TN [电子技术、通信技术];
学科分类号
0808 ; 0809 ;
摘要
Handwriting is preferred when people take notes or annotate during listening to lectures or reading documents. This paper proves the effects of handwriting experimentally. Two experiments using a dual task method revealed that the cognitive load of handwriting was smaller than that of typing and typing interfered with memorization more than handwriting. Moreover, this tendency was also observed for people who can type fast with touch typing. This indicates that handwriting has a strong advantage in keeping information without interfering with other cognitive activities regardless of people's typing skill.
引用
收藏
页码:255 / 261
页数:7
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] The cognitive distinction of having information by typing and handwriting
    He Wenhui
    Yang Wu
    Guo Ai
    Hong Zhang
    Bin Zuo
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY, 2012, 47 : 125 - 125
  • [2] Handwriting, Typing, and LaTeX
    Tempo, Roberto
    [J]. IEEE CONTROL SYSTEMS MAGAZINE, 2010, 30 (04): : 12 - 13
  • [3] COMPARING HANDWRITING SAMPLES
    不详
    [J]. KRIMINALISTIK, 1980, (06): : 251 - 251
  • [4] Handwriting or typing: occupational therapists' experiences of supporting young people with handwriting difficulties
    Nightingale, Ruth
    Barnett, Anna
    Sumner, Emma
    Prunty, Mellissa
    [J]. BRITISH JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY, 2022, 85 (8_SUPPL) : 20 - 21
  • [5] Handwriting and typing: Occupational therapy practice when supporting adolescents with handwriting difficulties
    Nightingale, Ruth
    Sumner, Emma
    Prunty, Mellissa
    Barnett, Anna L.
    [J]. BRITISH JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY, 2022, 85 (11) : 891 - 899
  • [6] Comparing the Handwriting Behaviours of True and False Writing with Computerized Handwriting Measures
    Luria, Gil
    Rosenblum, Sara
    [J]. APPLIED COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY, 2010, 24 (08) : 1115 - 1128
  • [7] Factors influencing student preference when comparing handwriting and typing for essay style examinations
    Mogey, Nora
    Fluck, Andrew
    [J]. BRITISH JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY, 2015, 46 (04) : 793 - 802
  • [8] The Effects of Using Handwriting Without Tears and a Handwriting Racetrack to Teach Five Preschool Students with Disabilities Pre Handwriting and Handwriting
    Delegato, Caitlin
    McLaughlin, T. F.
    Derby, K. Mark
    Schuster, Ladonna
    [J]. JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY SCHOOLS AND EARLY INTERVENTION, 2013, 6 (03): : 255 - 268
  • [9] EFFECTS OF TRAINING FOR MANUSCRIPT HANDWRITING ON GENERALIZATION TO CURSIVE HANDWRITING
    LEUNG, EKT
    TREBLAS, PV
    COOPER, JO
    PORTER, JT
    [J]. BEHAVIOURAL PSYCHOTHERAPY, 1982, 10 (04): : 311 - 323
  • [10] Students' choices between typing and handwriting in examinations
    Mogey, Nora
    Cowan, John
    Paterson, Jessie
    Purcell, Mike
    [J]. ACTIVE LEARNING IN HIGHER EDUCATION, 2012, 13 (02) : 117 - 128