REE measurements in the Bishopville aubrite confirm that oldhamite (CaS) is the dominant REE carrier, while most other phases, including the major silicates, are extremely REE-depleted. In oldhamite, a variety of REE patterns are observed, which could not have been produced during crystallization from a single fractionating magma. Although the aubrites have clearly undergone igneous processing, oldhamite (which is highly refractory) may be a relict phase . In this case, whole-rock REE data cannot provide information on the igneous evolution of these meteorites.