Growth and productivity performance of small manufacturing enterprises (SMEs) Insights from major states in India

Purpose -The purpose of this paper is to examine the performance of small manufacturing enterprises (SMEs) in India during the pre-reforms (prior to 1991) and reforms period (1991 onwards) with focus on 15 major states from different levels of development. Design/methodology/approach -In order to capture variation across different categories of states, 15 major states in India have been classified into high-, middle-and low-income states. Further, to capture productivity growth in the sector during the pre-reforms and reforms period, both partial factor productivity and total factor productivity method (growth accounting approach) have been adopted. The analysis is based on different rounds of nationwide survey conducted by the National Sample Survey Organization (NSSO) of the Government of India during 1978-2001. Findings -The findings of the study reveal erosion in growth of output in the SMEs during the reforms period as compared to the pre-reforms period with variation across different categories of states. The decline in growth of output during the reforms period can be primarily on account of fall in growth of employment and investment. The total factor productivity growth has also declined during the reforms period suggesting the need to enhance the level of technical efficiency and skills of the labour force in the sector. This is noticed in spite of major role played by the SMEs in providing employment (80 per cent of the total manufacturing sector employment) opportunities and in generating output (contributes 60 per cent of net domestic product) in the country. Research limitations/implications -On account of non-availability of annual data, the study relied on data collected by the NSSO of the Government of India periodically. In addition, the study did not examine the factors that explain decline in productivity growth in the sector. Originality/value -There is a large body of literature on regional growth and productivity in the Indian manufacturing sector but most of the studies have considered only the organized manufacturing sector. This study contributes to the literature by analyzing the inter-state variation in growth and productivity performance of SMEs in the pre-reforms and reforms periods.