A debate about Tim Crane's strategy against Twin Earth argument

被引：0

作者：

Andres Balsera, Silvia ^{[1
]}

机构：

[1] Univ Complutense Madrid, Fac Filosofia, Dept Log & Filosofia Ciencia, Madrid, Spain

来源：

REVISTA DE FILOSOFIA-MADRID | 2010年 / 35卷 / 02期

关键词：

individuation; psychological content; internalism; externalism; Twin Earth;

D O I：

暂无

中图分类号：

B [哲学、宗教];

学科分类号：

01 ; 0101 ;

摘要：

In his book Elements of mind Tim Crane has developed some resources in order to answer the Twin Earth mental experiment, invented by Hilary Putnam. The aim of this paper is to demonstrate that Crane's strategy is ineffective because he misunderstands that argument. We intend to examine in detail the reconstruction of the argument that Crane offers to detect its problems. A tighter version of it is also proposed, more consistent with Putnam intentions.

引用

页码：145 / 165

页数：21

共 6 条

[1] It's Not About Being Right: Developing Argument Through Debate
Malloy, Jacquelynn A.
Tracy, Kelly N.
Scales, Roya Q.
Menickelli, Kristin
Scales, W. David
[J]. JOURNAL OF LITERACY RESEARCH, 2020, 52 (01) : 79 - 100
[2] What on earth is Humanism? TIM CRANE AND PETER CAVE DEBATE WHETHER SECULAR HUMANISM ADDS UP TO A WORLD VIEW WORTH SUPPORTING
Crane, Tim
Cave, Peter
[J]. TPM-THE PHILOSOPHERS MAGAZINE, 2008, (41): : 55 - 62
[3] 'Now that's a fair dinkum academic debate, but this affects people's lives': a discursive analysis of arguments for and against the provision of warnings about potential side effects of SSRIs in a public debate
Williams, Anita
Donaghue, Ngaire
[J]. CRITICAL PUBLIC HEALTH, 2010, 20 (01) : 15 - 24
[4] Informational Co-option against Democracy: Comparing Bolsonaro's Discourses about Voting Machines with the Public Debate
de Moraes Silva, Ergon Cugler
Neves de Oliveira, Ana Gabrielle
[J]. PROCEEDINGS OF THE 16TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON THEORY AND PRACTICE OF ELECTRONIC GOVERNANCE, ICEGOV 2023, 2023, : 383 - 391
[5] John Locke's parity thesis about thinking matter: A response to Clifford Williams (An argument against the plausibility of a Christian form of physicalism)
Moreland, JP
[J]. RELIGIOUS STUDIES, 1998, 34 (03) : 253 - 259
[6] Did Oregon's tough mandatory sentencing law "measure 11" improve public safety? New evidence about an old debate from a multiple-design, experimental strategy
Sundt, Jody
Boppre, Breanna
[J]. JUSTICE QUARTERLY, 2021, 38 (07) : 1363 - 1384

← 1 →