Problems with “natural selection of academic papers”

被引：0
|
作者：
L. Egghe
机构：
[1] Universiteit Hasselt (Uhasselt),
[2] Universiteit Antwerpen (UA),undefined
来源：
Scientometrics | 2011年 / 88卷
关键词：
Peer review; Commercial publishing; Open access;
D O I：
暂无
中图分类号：
学科分类号：
摘要：
In this short communication we give critical comments on the paper of Perakakis et al. (Scientometrics 85(2):553–559, 2010) on “Natural selection of academic papers”. The criticism mainly focusses on their unbalanced criticism of peer review and their negative evaluation of the link of peer review with commercial publishing.
引用
收藏
页码：663 / 667
页数：4
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Problems with "natural selection of academic papers"
    Egghe, L.
    SCIENTOMETRICS, 2011, 88 (02) : 663 - 667
  • [2] Natural selection of academic papers
    Perakakis, Pandelis
    Taylor, Michael
    Mazza, Marco
    Trachana, Varvara
    SCIENTOMETRICS, 2010, 85 (02) : 553 - 559
  • [3] Natural selection of academic papers
    Pandelis Perakakis
    Michael Taylor
    Marco Mazza
    Varvara Trachana
    Scientometrics, 2010, 85 : 553 - 559
  • [4] Understanding the role of open peer review and dynamic academic articlesAuthors’ reply to “Problems with natural selection of academic papers”
    Pandelis Perakakis
    Michael Taylor
    Marco G. Mazza
    Varvara Trachana
    Scientometrics, 2011, 88 : 669 - 673
  • [5] Understanding the role of open peer review and dynamic academic articles: Authors' reply to "Problems with natural selection of academic papers"
    Perakakis, Pandelis
    Taylor, Michael
    Mazza, Marco G.
    Trachana, Varvara
    SCIENTOMETRICS, 2011, 88 (02) : 669 - 673
  • [6] Congestion of Academic Journals Under Papers' Imperfect Selection
    Besancenot, Damien
    Faria, Joao R.
    Huynh, Kim V.
    B E JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC ANALYSIS & POLICY, 2014, 14 (03): : 1145 - 1167
  • [7] Problems for Natural Selection as a Mechanism
    Havstad, Joyce C.
    PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 2011, 78 (03) : 512 - 523
  • [8] Editors' selection of papers from China's academic journals
    National Science Review, 2015, (02) : 131 - 132
  • [9] Editors' selection of papers from China's academic journals
    Gao Y.
    Gao, Yuan, 2018, Oxford University Press (05): : 123 - 125
  • [10] Editors' selection of papers from China's academic journals
    National Science Review, 2017, (05) : 669 - 671
12345