Ethics of Nuclear Energy in Times of Climate Change: Escaping the Collective Action Problem

被引:0
|
作者
Friederich S. [1 ]
Boudry M. [2 ]
机构
[1] University of Groningen, University College Groningen, Hoendiepskade 23/24, Groningen
[2] Department of Philosophy and Moral Sciences, University of Ghent, Blandijnberg 2, Ghent
关键词
Climate change; Decarbonization; Ethics; Non-proliferation; Nuclear energy;
D O I
10.1007/s13347-022-00527-1
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
In recent years, there has been an intense public debate about whether and, if so, to what extent investments in nuclear energy should be part of strategies to mitigate climate change. Here, we address this question from an ethical perspective, evaluating different strategies of energy system development in terms of three ethical criteria, which will differentially appeal to proponents of different normative ethical frameworks. Starting from a standard analysis of climate change as arising from an intergenerational collective action problem, we evaluate whether contributions from nuclear energy will, on expectation, increase the likelihood of successfully phasing out fossil fuels in time to avert dangerous global warming. For many socio-economic and geographic contexts, our review of the energy system modeling literature suggests the answer to this question is “yes.” We conclude that, from the point of view of climate change mitigation, investments in nuclear energy as part of a broader energy portfolio will be ethically required to minimize the risks of decarbonization failure, and thus the tail risks of catastrophic global warming. Finally, using a sensitivity analysis, we consider which other aspects of nuclear energy deployment, apart from climate change, have the potential to overturn the ultimate ethical verdict on investments in nuclear energy. Out of several potential considerations (e.g., nuclear waste, accidents, safety), we suggest that its potential interplay — whether beneficial or adverse — with the proliferation of nuclear weapons is the most plausible candidate. © 2022, The Author(s).
引用
收藏
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Sustainability, Ethics and Nuclear Energy: Escaping the Dichotomy
    Kermisch, Celine
    Taebi, Behnam
    [J]. SUSTAINABILITY, 2017, 9 (03):
  • [2] Return to the Isle of Ted: Simulating the Collective Action Problem of Climate Change
    Mitchell, Jocelyn Sage
    [J]. PS-POLITICAL SCIENCE & POLITICS, 2020, 53 (03) : 547 - 555
  • [3] Collective action needed on climate change
    不详
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL GAS ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT, 2006, 46 (03): : 25 - 25
  • [4] The Problem of Climate Change in Historical Times
    Eckardt, W. R.
    [J]. PETERMANNS MITTEILUNGEN, 1916, 62 : 33 - 33
  • [5] The Problem of Climate Change in historical Times
    Ward, R. DeC.
    [J]. BULLETIN OF THE AMERICAN GEOGRAPHICAL SOCIETY OF NEW YORK, 1915, 47 (02): : 145 - 145
  • [6] Oil shortages, climate change and collective action
    Newbery, David
    [J]. PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY A-MATHEMATICAL PHYSICAL AND ENGINEERING SCIENCES, 2011, 369 (1942): : 1748 - 1761
  • [7] Nuclear Energy & Climate Change
    Agnihotri, Newal
    Meserve, Richard A.
    [J]. NUCLEAR PLANT JOURNAL, 2011, 29 (03) : 24 - 24
  • [8] Residents' participation in energy performance certification for collective action on climate change: the case of EnerGuide
    Chen, Xinyu
    Gou, Zhonghua
    Zhang, Huihua
    [J]. FRONTIERS IN PSYCHOLOGY, 2023, 14
  • [9] Climate Change Mitigation and the Collective Action Problem: Exploring Country Differences in Greenhouse Gas Contributions
    Brechin, Steven R.
    [J]. SOCIOLOGICAL FORUM, 2016, 31 : 846 - 861
  • [10] "Change With The Times": The Practice of Nuclear Medicine in the Time of Climate Change
    Michaud, Jean-Paul
    Monteparo, Isidora
    Thompson, Kevin
    Kohanzad, Sabrina
    Choe, Erin
    Dobtsis, Joseph
    Meshekow, Jared
    Gerard, Perry
    [J]. JOURNAL OF NUCLEAR MEDICINE, 2021, 62