Aluminum and calcium distribution patterns in aluminum-intoxicated roots of Allium cepa do not support the calcium-displacement hypothesis and indicate signal-mediated inhibition of root growth

The aluminum and calcium distributions in the root tips of aluminum-intoxicated onions, Allium cepa L., were mapped using PIXE (particle-induced X-ray emission) microanalysis. Not enough aluminum was present to have replaced, atom-for-atom, more than a minor fraction of the calcium. Furthermore, no inverse relationship between variations in aluminum and calcium concentrations was observed for pairs of adjacent 30-μm-diameter regions. Our observations, therefore, do not support the hypothesis that aluminum substantially reduces the quantity of bound calcium by competing with calcium for binding sites. Instead we suggest that reductions in calcium content are a non-local and indirect consequence of aluminum-intoxication. We found that aluminum accumulates almost exclusively in a surface layer. Observations of wounded roots indicated that exposed internal tissue binds aluminum avidly, so we contend that the surface accumulation pattern indicates that little aluminum penetrates into the interior of the root. We argue that aluminum does not directly inhibit growth in the interior of the apical root meristem because root growth rate was unaffected by root cap removal which should greatly increase the aluminum concentration in the exposed interior region. We hypothesize that growth inhibition in the interior of the meristem is mediated by a signal initiated or disrupted by excess aluminum in the periphery of the meristem.