Does Quantitative Ultrasound of Bone Reflect More Bone Mineral Density Than Bone Microarchitecture?

Relationships among quantitative ultrasound of bone (QUS), bone mineral density (BMD) and bone microarchitecture have been poorly investigated in human calcaneus. .Twenty-four specimens, from 12 men and 12 women (mean age 78 ± 10 years; range 53–93), removed from cadavers were studied. The feet were axially sectioned above the ankle. Two variables were measured for QUS (Achilles®, Lunar): broadband ultrasound attenuation (BUA) and speed of sound (SOS). A third variable, the stiffness index (SI), which is a combination of both BUA and SOS, was also calculated. BMD (a lateral view) was measured on a QDR 2000 densitometer (Hologic). Bone microarchitecture was assessed by computed tomography (CT) using a conventional CT-system. Fifteen sagittal sections (1 mm in width and 2 mm apart) were selected for CT. Methods used for characterizing bone microarchitecture consisted in structural (trabecular network characterization) and a fractal analyses. The relationships between QUS and bone microarchitecture were assessed by simple linear regression analysis with and without adjustment for BMD (partial correlation) and by backward stepwise regression analysis. Strong relationships were found between BMD and QUS. Adjusted r2 values were 0.545 for SOS and 0.717 for SI. Two microarchitectural variables were also significantly correlated with both SOS and SI: apparent trabecular separation (App Tr Sp) and trabecular bone pattern factor (App TBPF). After adjustment for BMD few correlations between QUS and microarchitectural variables were always significant. Adjusted squared semipartial coefficients of correlation (rsp2) values between SOS and bone microarchitecture were 6%, 6.8%, 13.2% and 4.6% for App BV/TV, App Tr Sp, App TBPF and fractal dimension (FD), respectively. For SI, corresponding figures were 3.7%, 4.1%, 5.2% and 3.2%. Backward stepwise regression analysis using BMD and microarchitecture showed a slight increase of r2 values that varied from 8.4% for SI to 17.8% for SOS, compared with BMD alone. The current study suggests that although BMD is a major determinant of acoustic properties of human calcaneus, significant density independent relationships with bone microarchitecture should also be taken into account.