Systematic literature review shows that appetite rating does not predict energy intake

被引:44
|
作者
Holt, Guy M. [1 ]
Owen, Lauren J. [2 ]
Till, Sophie [1 ]
Cheng, Yanying [1 ]
Grant, Vicky A. [1 ]
Harden, Charlotte J. [1 ]
Corfe, Bernard M. [1 ,3 ]
机构
[1] Univ Sheffield, Acad Unit Surg Oncol, Sch Med, Mol Gastroenterol Res Grp, Sheffield, S Yorkshire, England
[2] Univ Cent Lancashire, Dept Psychol, Preston, Lancs, England
[3] Univ Sheffield, Insigneo Inst Silico Med, Sheffield, S Yorkshire, England
关键词
Appetite; self-report appetite; appetite rating scales; visual analogue scales; energy intake; systematic review; GLUCAGON-LIKE PEPTIDE-1; GLP-1 ANALOG LIRAGLUTIDE; FOOD-INTAKE; REPRODUCIBILITY; SATIETY; PRELOAD;
D O I
10.1080/10408398.2016.1246414
中图分类号
TS2 [食品工业];
学科分类号
0832 ;
摘要
Ratings of appetite are commonly used to assess appetite modification following an intervention. Subjectively rated appetite is a widely employed proxy measure for energy intake (EI), measurement of which requires greater time and resources. However, the validity of appetite as a reliable predictor of EI has not yet been reviewed systematically. This literature search identified studies that quantified both appetite ratings and EI. Outcomes were predefined as: (1) agreement between self-reported appetite scores and EI; (2) no agreement between self-reported appetitescores and EI. The presence of direct statistical comparison between the endpoints, intervention type and study population were also recorded. 462 papers were included in this review. Appetite scores failed to correspond with EI in 51.3% of the total studies. Only 6% of all studies evaluated here reported a direct statistical comparison between appetite scores and EI. (2) analysis demonstrated that any relationship between EI and appetite was independent of study type stratification by age, gender or sample size. The very substantive corpus reviewed allows us to conclude that self-reported appetite ratings of appetite do not reliably predict EI. Caution should be exercised when drawing conclusions based from self-reported appetite scores in relation to prospective EI.
引用
收藏
页码:3577 / 3582
页数:6
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Systematic Literature Review Shows That Appetite Rating does Not Predict Energy Intake
    Holt, Guy M.
    Owen, Lauren J.
    Till, Sophie
    Cheng, Yanying
    Grant, Vicky A.
    Harden, Charlotte J.
    Corfe, Bernard M.
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE NUTRITION SOCIETY, 2016, 75 (OCE3) : E179 - E179
  • [2] Appetite is not a reliable predictor of energy intake: interim reporting of a systematic literature review
    Till, S.
    Harden, C. J.
    Grant, V. A.
    Corfe, B. M.
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE NUTRITION SOCIETY, 2015, 74 (OCE1) : E150 - E150
  • [3] Does protein supplementation impact appetite and energy intake in older adults? A systematic review
    Ben-Harchache, Sana
    Homer, Katy
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE NUTRITION SOCIETY, 2020, 79 (OCE2) : E610 - E610
  • [4] Impact of Resistance Training on Energy Intake and Appetite Regulation for Obese or Overweight Individuals: A Systematic Literature Review
    Wang, Qiang
    Geok, Soh Kim
    Gan, Wan Ying
    Sun, He
    Luo, Sheng Yao
    REVISTA DE PSICOLOGIA DEL DEPORTE, 2024, 33 (01): : 187 - 200
  • [5] The effect of gastrointestinal bitter sensing on appetite regulation and energy intake: A systematic review
    Hassan, Luke
    Newman, Lisa
    Keast, Russell
    Danaher, Jessica
    Biesiekierski, Jessica R.
    APPETITE, 2023, 180
  • [6] Effects of Vinegar/Acetic Acid Intake on Appetite Measures and Energy Consumption: Systematic Review
    Hasan, Faten O.
    Hamilton, Kristen P.
    Angadi, Siddhartha S.
    Kranz, Sibylle
    TRANSLATIONAL JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF SPORTS MEDICINE, 2022, 7 (03)
  • [7] The relationship between physical activity, appetite and energy intake in older adults: A systematic review
    Clegg, M. E.
    Godfrey, A.
    APPETITE, 2018, 128 : 145 - 151
  • [8] A systematic review of the effect of oral glucocorticoids on energy intake, appetite, and body weight in humans
    Berthon, Bronwyn S.
    MacDonald-Wicks, Lesley K.
    Wood, Lisa G.
    NUTRITION RESEARCH, 2014, 34 (03) : 179 - 190
  • [9] Systematic review of the evidence for sustained efficacy of dietary interventions for reducing appetite or energy intake
    Halford, Jason C. G.
    Masic, Una
    Marsaux, Cyril F. M.
    Jones, Andrew J.
    Lluch, Anne
    Marciani, Luca
    Mars, Monica
    Vinoy, Sophie
    Westerterp-Plantenga, Margriet
    Mela, David J.
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE NUTRITION SOCIETY, 2020, 79 (OCE2) : E247 - E247
  • [10] Systematic review of the evidence for sustained efficacy of dietary interventions for reducing appetite or energy intake
    Halford, J. C. G.
    Masic, U.
    Marsaux, C. F. M.
    Jones, A. J.
    Lluch, A.
    Marciani, L.
    Mars, M.
    Vinoy, S.
    Westerterp-Plantenga, M.
    Mela, D. J.
    OBESITY REVIEWS, 2018, 19 (10) : 1329 - 1339