PIOUS AND CRITICAL: Muslim Women Activists and the Question of Agency

Recent turmoil in the Middle East and North Africa has prompted renewed concerns about women's rights in Muslim societies. It has also raised questions about women's agency and activism in religious contexts. This article draws on ethnographic research with women activists in Indonesia, the country with the world's largest Muslim population, to address such concerns. My fieldwork shows that some Muslim women activists in democratizing Indonesia manifest pious critical agency. Pious critical agency is the capacity to engage critically and publicly with religious texts. While some scholars have argued that pious and feminist subjectivity are inherently at odds, the emergence of pious critical agency in Indonesia demonstrates that piety and feminism can intersect in surprising and unexpected ways. Moreover, it shows that women's agency can draw on both secular and religious resources and that religion can be used to promote critical discourses on gender.