Research Review: The most effective parenting program content for disruptive child behavior - a network meta-analysis

被引:24
|
作者
Leijten, Patty [1 ]
Melendez-Torres, G. J. [2 ]
Gardner, Frances [3 ]
机构
[1] Univ Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[2] Univ Exeter, Exeter, Devon, England
[3] Univ Oxford, Oxford, England
关键词
Parenting program; disruptive child behavior; effective components; systematic review; network meta-analysis; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED-TRIAL; TRAINING-PROGRAM; INTERVENTIONS; THERAPY;
D O I
10.1111/jcpp.13483
中图分类号
B844 [发展心理学(人类心理学)];
学科分类号
040202 ;
摘要
Background: Programs to support parents are the recommended strategy to reduce disruptive child behavior problems. Efforts have been made to demonstrate which program components (i.e., clusters of techniques taught) increase program effects, but these methods fail to account for the fact that components rarely operate in isolation. We examine how combinations of components cluster together to form program types and use network meta-analysis to estimate the relative effects of these program types. Methods: We updated an existing systematic review of parenting programs for disruptive child behavior and identified 197 randomized trials. We modeled clusters of components in each trial arm and chose the best-fitting model. We subsequently took 20 draws from the probability distribution of the latent class for each arm, entered each draw into a network meta-analysis model and combined findings using Rubin's rules. Combined estimates were bootstrapped to rank the clusters. We estimated main models and separate models for prevention and treatment settings. Results: A five-class solution fit the data best: (1) behavior management; (2) behavior management with parental self-management; (3) behavior management with psychoeducation and relationship enhancement; (4) maximal component loading and (5) no/minimal component loading (i.e. control). In the main model and in treatment settings, all four program types were effective compared to no/minimal components. In prevention settings, only behavior management and behavior management with parental self-management were effective compared to no/minimal components. Probabilistic ranking showed that overall and in treatment settings, behavior management had the largest chance, and in prevention settings, behavior management with self-management had the largest chance, of being most effective compared to no/minimal components. Conclusions: Programs with more focused content seem more likely to yield stronger effects, and different foci may be needed in treatment versus prevention settings. Next steps include identifying individual family differences in optimal program content.
引用
收藏
页码:132 / 142
页数:11
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Parenting Programs for Disruptive Child Behavior in China: A Meta-Analysis and Systematic Review
    Hua, Ningxuan
    Leijten, Patty
    [J]. RESEARCH ON SOCIAL WORK PRACTICE, 2022, 32 (01) : 32 - 48
  • [2] Disruptive Child Behavior Severity and Parenting Program Session Attendance: Individual Participant Data Meta-Analysis
    Melendez-Torres, G. J.
    Leijten, Patty
    Scott, Stephen
    Gardner, Frances
    Axford, Nick
    Seabra Santos, Maria Joao
    Menting, Ankie
    Hutchings, Judy
    Berry, Vashti
    [J]. JOURNAL OF CONSULTING AND CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY, 2024,
  • [3] The Impact of Foster Parent Training on Parenting Skills and Child Disruptive Behavior: A Meta-Analysis
    Solomon, David T.
    Niec, Larissa N.
    Schoonover, Ciera E.
    [J]. CHILD MALTREATMENT, 2017, 22 (01) : 3 - 13
  • [4] Meta-Analyses: Key Parenting Program Components for Disruptive Child Behavior
    Leijten, Patty
    Gardner, Frances
    Melendez-Torres, G. J.
    van Aar, Jolien
    Hutchings, Judy
    Schulz, Susanne
    Knerr, Wendy
    Overbeek, Geertjan
    [J]. JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF CHILD AND ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY, 2019, 58 (02): : 180 - 190
  • [5] Sustained, fade-out or sleeper effects? A systematic review and meta-analysis of parenting interventions for disruptive child behavior
    van Aar, Jolien
    Leijten, Patty
    de Castro, Bram Orobio
    Overbeek, Geertjan
    [J]. CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY REVIEW, 2017, 51 : 153 - 163
  • [6] Parenting Behavior and Child Language: A Meta-analysis
    Madigan, Sheri
    Prime, Heather
    Graham, Susan A.
    Rodrigues, Michelle
    Anderson, Nina
    Khoury, Jennifer
    Jenkins, Jennifer M.
    [J]. PEDIATRICS, 2019, 144 (04)
  • [7] Psychopharmacological treatment of disruptive behavior in youths: systematic review and network meta-analysis
    Seok, Ji-Woo
    Soltis-Vaughan, Brigette
    Lew, Brandon J.
    Ahmad, Aatiya
    Blair, R. J. R.
    Hwang, Soonjo
    [J]. SCIENTIFIC REPORTS, 2023, 13 (01)
  • [8] Psychopharmacological treatment of disruptive behavior in youths: systematic review and network meta-analysis
    Ji-Woo Seok
    Brigette Soltis-Vaughan
    Brandon J. Lew
    Aatiya Ahmad
    R. J. R. Blair
    Soonjo Hwang
    [J]. Scientific Reports, 13
  • [9] The effectiveness of parenting program components on disruptive and delinquent behaviors during early and middle childhood: a component network meta-analysis
    Tehrani, Hossein Dabiriyan
    Yamini, Sara
    Vazsonyi, Alexander T.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL CRIMINOLOGY, 2023,
  • [10] Study Preregistration: Individual Participant Data Meta-Analysis: Individual Differences in Mediators of Parenting Program Effects on Disruptive Behavior
    Siguroardottir, Liina Bjorg Laas
    Melendez-Torres, G. J.
    Backhaus, Sophia
    Gardner, Frances
    Scott, Stephen
    Leijten, Patty
    [J]. JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF CHILD AND ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY, 2024, 63 (04): : 464 - 467